Meletti Stefano, Cantalupo Gaetano, Stanzani-Maserati Michelangelo, Rubboli Guido, Alberto Tassinari Carlo
Division of Neurology-Bellaria Hospital, University of Bologna, Via Altura No. 3, 40139, Bologna, Italy.
Epilepsy Behav. 2003 Dec;4(6):635-43. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2003.09.004.
By videotape recordings analysis we investigated the frequencies of interictal, preictal, and postictal wiping or rubbing movements targeting the face region (face wiping, FW) in 17 right and 13 left mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (MTLE) patients. Patients' data were compared with FW frequencies obtained in 22 healthy controls listening to a presentation. Results showed that: (1) FW movements were present in both controls and patients; however, the patient groups showed lower interictal and preictal FW rates relative than controls; (2) right and left temporal lobe seizures were followed by a marked increase in the expression of wiping activities directed to the nose as well as to other face regions with respect to the interictal-preictal period; (3) during the first 5min postictal FW was performed preferentially with the hand ipsilateral to the seizure focus; (4) postictal examination of the patient by an observer, especially if of the opposite sex, resulted in a higher incidence of FW acts. After temporal lobe seizures there is an exaggerated expression of movements targeting the face region, and not exclusively directed to the nose. According to an ethological interpretation of the FW behavior as a motor behavior present throughout the phylogenetic scale, from rodents to primates, we suggest the postictal emergence of an innate action pattern modulated by external emotional-cognitive stimuli.
通过录像分析,我们调查了17例右侧和13例左侧颞叶内侧癫痫(MTLE)患者发作间期、发作前期和发作后期针对面部区域的擦拭或摩擦动作(面部擦拭,FW)的频率。将患者的数据与22名听讲座的健康对照者的FW频率进行比较。结果显示:(1)对照组和患者均存在FW动作;然而,患者组发作间期和发作前期的FW发生率低于对照组;(2)与发作间期-发作前期相比,右侧和左侧颞叶癫痫发作后,针对鼻子以及其他面部区域的擦拭活动明显增加;(3)在发作后最初5分钟内,FW动作优先由与癫痫病灶同侧的手进行;(4)观察者对患者进行发作后检查,尤其是异性观察者,会导致FW动作的发生率更高。颞叶癫痫发作后,针对面部区域的动作会过度表达,且并非仅针对鼻子。根据将FW行为作为一种在从啮齿动物到灵长类动物的整个系统发育尺度上都存在的运动行为的行为学解释,我们认为发作后出现了一种由外部情绪-认知刺激调节的先天动作模式。