Gianoli G J, Mann W J, Miller R H
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Tulane University Medical Center, New Orleans, LA 70112.
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1992 Dec;107(6 Pt 1):713-20. doi: 10.1177/019459988910700601.1.
Ultrasound as a diagnostic aid in the evaluation of the sinuses has been a controversial issue. Sensitivities have been reported from 29% to 100% and specificities from 55% to 99%. These wide variations in results from previous studies may have resulted from technical differences. However, the "gold standard" most often used for comparison has been a Water's view radiograph, which has been shown to correlate poorly with intraoperative and CT scan findings. To our knowledge, no one in the English language literature has evaluated sonography of the sinuses with computed tomography as the gold standard. In addition, evaluation of the ethmoid sinus has been neglected by previous studies that have primarily assessed the maxillary sinus. We report the results of a blinded, prospective trial comprised of 41 patients examined by B-mode ultrasound with comparison to computed tomography. Frontal and maxillary sinuses were examined with traditional sonographic techniques and the ethmoid sinuses were scanned with a transglobe technique not previously evaluated in the English language literature. Excluding isolated mucous retention cysts and focal minimal mucosal thickening (defined as < 4 mm), sensitivities for ultrasound of the maxillary, frontal, and ethmoid sinuses were 100% each. Specificities were 98% for the maxillary sinus, 100% for the frontal sinus, and 94% for the ethmoid sinus. Technical aspects and implications of this and previous reports will be discussed.
超声作为鼻窦评估的诊断辅助手段一直是一个有争议的问题。据报道,其敏感度在29%至100%之间,特异度在55%至99%之间。以往研究结果的这些巨大差异可能是由技术差异导致的。然而,最常被用作比较的“金标准”是华氏位X线片,而它已被证明与术中及CT扫描结果的相关性较差。据我们所知,英文文献中没有人以计算机断层扫描作为金标准来评估鼻窦的超声检查。此外,以往的研究主要评估上颌窦,而忽略了筛窦的评估。我们报告了一项由41例患者组成的盲法前瞻性试验的结果,这些患者接受了B型超声检查,并与计算机断层扫描进行了比较。采用传统超声技术检查额窦和上颌窦,采用一种此前英文文献中未评估过的经眼球技术扫描筛窦。排除孤立的黏液潴留囊肿和局灶性轻度黏膜增厚(定义为<4mm)后,上颌窦、额窦和筛窦超声检查的敏感度均为100%。上颌窦的特异度为98%,额窦为100%,筛窦为94%。本文将讨论此项研究及以往报告的技术方面和意义。