Reissman Debi, Price Tom, Leibman Christopher W
Rxperts, Irvine, CA 92618,
J Manag Care Pharm. 2004 Jan;10(1 Suppl):S9-13.
Effective treatment of seasonal or perennial allergic rhinitis often requires use of topical intranasal corticosteroids (INSs). Despite differences in recommended starting dosages, the 4 leading INSs by market share are packaged in bottles containing 120 metered-dose sprays.
To determine the relative prescribed dosages of the leading INSs and compare economic differences resulting from these prescribing behaviors.
The IMS National Disease and Therapeutic Index (NDTI) was used to identify prescribing habits for the 4 leading INSs: fluticasone propionate nasal spray (FPNS), mometasone furoate aqueous nasal spray (MFNS), triamcinolone acetonide aqueous nasal spray (TANS), and budesonide aqueous nasal spray (BANS). The NDTI uses a national, randomly drawn, 2-stage stratified clustersampling methodology. Physicians are sampled during the first stage, with 2 workdays per month subsampled from each physician in the second stage. Each physician reports on all patient contacts during the 2 consecutive days, offering a continuing compilation of statistical information about patterns and treatment of disease encountered by office-based physicians. In a given month, the NDTI reports on 1180 unique physicians.
From January 1, 2002, to December 31, 2002, 58% of prescriptions for FPNS were for 4 sprays daily with 37% for 2 sprays daily, MFNS: 44% for 4 sprays and 52% for 2, TANS: 65% for 4 sprays and 31% for 2, and BANS: 29% for 4 sprays and 68% for 2. These equated to mean prescribed daily dosages of 3.47 sprays per day for FPNS, 3.33 for MFNS, 3.50 for TANS, and 2.73 for BANS. Because each INS is packaged in a bottle with 120 metered-dose sprays, the differences in dosage offer varying days of supply per unit filled. BANS offered the most days of treatment (44 days), followed by MFNS (38 days) and FPNS and TANS (means of 35 and 34 days, respectively) per single prescription filled. Cost per day of treatment was calculated by multiplying the prescribed dosage with the average wholesale price of the products. BANS had the lowest cost per day of treatment at US dollars 1.54, with each other INS costing at least an additional US dollars 0.26 daily (MFNS US dollars 1.80; FPNS US dollars 1.88; TANS US dollars 1.97).
Based on physician prescribing patterns of INSs from the NDTI database, BANS offers more days of treatment at a lower cost per day than other leading INSs.
季节性或常年性变应性鼻炎的有效治疗通常需要使用鼻用糖皮质激素(INS)。尽管推荐的起始剂量有所不同,但市场份额领先的4种主要INS均包装为含有120揿定量喷雾剂的瓶子。
确定主要INS的相对处方剂量,并比较这些处方行为导致的经济差异。
使用IMS全国疾病和治疗指数(NDTI)来确定4种主要INS的处方习惯:丙酸氟替卡松鼻喷雾剂(FPNS)、糠酸莫米松水鼻喷雾剂(MFNS)、曲安奈德水鼻喷雾剂(TANS)和布地奈德水鼻喷雾剂(BANS)。NDTI采用全国随机抽取的两阶段分层整群抽样方法。在第一阶段对医生进行抽样,在第二阶段从每位医生每月中抽取2个工作日进行抽样。每位医生报告连续2天内所有的患者接触情况,从而持续汇编关于门诊医生遇到的疾病模式和治疗的统计信息。在给定的一个月中,NDTI报告1180名不同的医生。
从2002年1月1日至2002年12月31日,FPNS的处方中58%为每日4揿,37%为每日2揿;MFNS:44%为每日4揿,52%为每日2揿;TANS:65%为每日4揿,31%为每日2揿;BANS:29%为每日4揿,68%为每日2揿。这些相当于FPNS的平均每日处方剂量为3.47揿/天,MFNS为3.33揿/天,TANS为3.50揿/天,BANS为2.73揿/天。由于每种INS均包装在含有120揿定量喷雾剂的瓶子中,剂量差异导致每剂填充的供应天数不同。每填充一张处方,BANS提供的治疗天数最多(44天),其次是MFNS(38天)以及FPNS和TANS(分别平均为35天和34天)。通过将处方剂量与产品的平均批发价格相乘来计算每日治疗成本。BANS的每日治疗成本最低,为1.54美元,其他每种INS的每日成本至少额外增加0.26美元(MFNS为1.80美元;FPNS为1.88美元;TANS为1.97美元)。
基于NDTI数据库中医生对INS的处方模式,与其他主要INS相比,BANS以更低的每日成本提供更多的治疗天数。