Al Jarad N, Uthayakumar S, Buckland E J, Green T S, Ord J, Newland A C, Rudd R M
London Chest Hospital.
Br J Ind Med. 1992 Dec;49(12):826-31. doi: 10.1136/oem.49.12.826.
Thirty nine phenotypes of human leucocyte antigens (HLA)-A-B-DR and DQ were obtained from 99 asbestos workers (one woman and 98 men). Presence or absence of antinuclear antibodies and rheumatoid factor was determined in 91 of them. Workers were divided into five groups: asbestos workers with no apparent disease (AW; n = 17), diffuse benign pleural disease (PD; n = 31), asbestosis (AS; n = 24), asbestosis with lung cancer (AS-CA; n = 14), and mesothelioma (M; n = 13). Compared with AW, several trends of differences of HLA antigen prevalence were found in patients with asbestos related disease, but these did not achieve statistical significance when p was corrected (pcorr) by number of analyses undertaken. Analysis of the results obtained in previous studies together with the results of this study showed that compared with AW, AS patients had decreased prevalence of HLA-DR5 (pcorr < 0.02). Reasons for the differences in results of previous studies and statistical methods commonly used to compare prevalences of HLA antigen are discussed.
从99名石棉工人(1名女性和98名男性)中获得了39种人类白细胞抗原(HLA)-A-B-DR和DQ的表型。其中91人检测了抗核抗体和类风湿因子的存在与否。工人们被分为五组:无明显疾病的石棉工人(AW;n = 17)、弥漫性良性胸膜疾病(PD;n = 31)、石棉肺(AS;n = 24)、石棉肺合并肺癌(AS-CA;n = 14)和间皮瘤(M;n = 13)。与AW相比,在石棉相关疾病患者中发现了HLA抗原患病率的几种差异趋势,但在通过进行的分析次数校正p值(pcorr)后,这些差异未达到统计学意义。对先前研究结果与本研究结果的分析表明,与AW相比,AS患者的HLA-DR5患病率降低(pcorr < 0.02)。讨论了先前研究结果差异的原因以及常用于比较HLA抗原患病率的统计方法。