Welham Nathan V, Rousseau Bernard, Ford Charles N, Bless Diane M
Department of Surgery, Division of Otolaryngology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, USA.
J Voice. 2003 Dec;17(4):571-8. doi: 10.1067/s0892-1997(03)00086-9.
Outcomes data after a surgical or behavioral intervention should be tracked until stability is reached. Often it is unclear how long patients should be followed and at what point an outcome can be considered stable. These issues have implications for treatment decision making, efficacy measurement, and the design of research studies. Vocal function data were collected 24 hours before and at 1, 6, and 12 months after phonosurgery for sulcus vocalis. One data series was collected daily during the first month after surgery, providing a unique opportunity to study voice changes in the immediate postoperative period. The different vocal function indices (acoustic, perceptual, videostroboscopic, aerodynamic, psychosocial) demonstrated a general pattern of improvement after intervention; however, they appeared to reach stability at different times. This report reinforces the value of following patients until complete outcome stability.
手术或行为干预后的结果数据应持续跟踪,直至达到稳定状态。通常,不清楚患者应随访多长时间以及在何时可认为结果稳定。这些问题对治疗决策、疗效评估和研究设计都有影响。对声带沟的嗓音外科手术前后24小时、术后1个月、6个月和12个月收集嗓音功能数据。术后第一个月每天收集一个数据系列,这为研究术后即刻的嗓音变化提供了独特机会。不同的嗓音功能指标(声学、感知、视频频闪、空气动力学、心理社会)在干预后呈现出总体改善模式;然而,它们似乎在不同时间达到稳定。本报告强调了对患者进行随访直至结果完全稳定的价值。