Tabacova Sonia, Little Ruth, Tsong Yi, Vega Amarilys, Kimmel Carole A
National Center for Toxicological Research, US Food and Drug Administration, Center for Drug Evaluation and Research, DNDP, HFD-120, 5600 Fishers Lane, Rockville, MD 20857, USA.
Pharmacoepidemiol Drug Saf. 2003 Dec;12(8):633-46. doi: 10.1002/pds.796.
Adverse pregnancy outcomes following the use of angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors, including enalapril, have been reported in descriptive studies. However, no analytical studies on the relationship between the adverse outcomes and enalapril gestational exposures are available.
To explore the association between enalapril exposure and adverse outcomes in pregnancy, taking into account other possible risk factors.
We analyzed a series of all usable cases reported to the FDA between 1986 and 2000 in which enalapril was a suspect drug for the observed adverse outcomes (N = 110). Parameters of exposure and reported outcomes as well as information on potentially confounding variables were systematically abstracted from this series by a single physician. Because exposure to ACE inhibitors after the first trimester of pregnancy had been associated with adverse outcomes in the existing literature, we divided the cases into those exposed in the first trimester only (considered as the baseline group) and cases exposed beyond or after this time. Frequency of reported adverse outcomes in the second group was compared with those in the baseline group; odds ratios were computed, taking account of potentially confounding variables by logistic regression where appropriate.
Exposure to enalapril after the first trimester of pregnancy was strongly associated with oligohydramnios and specific adverse outcomes thought to be secondary to reduced amniotic fluid volume (limb deformities, cranial ossification deficits, lung hypoplasia), as well as with neonatal renal failure. The relationship did not change after taking numerous potential confounders into account, including duration of exposure, concomitant drug use, maternal age, concurrent disease, neonatal gender, and gestational age at birth. Such a pattern of abnormalities is considered to be a consequence of the effect of ACE inhibition on fetal renal function that develops after the first trimester.
The specificity and temporality of the observed adverse manifestations suggest a causal relationship to enalapril exposure.
在描述性研究中已报道了使用包括依那普利在内的血管紧张素转换酶(ACE)抑制剂后出现的不良妊娠结局。然而,尚无关于不良结局与依那普利孕期暴露之间关系的分析性研究。
考虑其他可能的危险因素,探讨依那普利暴露与妊娠不良结局之间的关联。
我们分析了1986年至2000年间向美国食品药品监督管理局(FDA)报告的一系列所有可用病例,其中依那普利是观察到的不良结局的可疑药物(N = 110)。由一名医生从该系列病例中系统地提取暴露参数、报告的结局以及潜在混杂变量的信息。由于在现有文献中,妊娠中期后接触ACE抑制剂与不良结局相关,我们将病例分为仅在孕早期接触的病例(视为基线组)和在此时间之后或之后接触的病例。将第二组报告的不良结局频率与基线组进行比较;计算比值比,并在适当情况下通过逻辑回归考虑潜在的混杂变量。
妊娠中期后接触依那普利与羊水过少以及被认为继发于羊水量减少的特定不良结局(肢体畸形、颅骨骨化缺陷、肺发育不全)以及新生儿肾衰竭密切相关。在考虑了众多潜在混杂因素后,这种关系并未改变,这些因素包括暴露持续时间、同时使用的药物、产妇年龄、并发疾病、新生儿性别和出生时的孕周。这种异常模式被认为是ACE抑制对孕中期后发育的胎儿肾功能产生影响的结果。
观察到的不良表现的特异性和时间性表明与依那普利暴露存在因果关系。