Crossley D, Myres M P, Wilkinson G
Academic Department of Psychiatry, London Hospital Medical College.
BMJ. 1992 Nov 28;305(6865):1333-6. doi: 10.1136/bmj.305.6865.1333.
To pilot a method of assessing psychological care by general practitioners.
Prospective examination of psychological care given in general practice by using general health questionnaire with predetermined quantifiable and case specific indices of outcome established at the original consultation.
Rural general practice in Clwyd, North Wales.
447 consecutive adult general practice attenders.
Three month follow up consultation rates, one year retrospective consultation rates, continuity of care, changes in general health questionnaire scores at follow up, general satisfaction, and acceptability of outcome measures.
The principal and trainee identified 72 patients with psychological problems, 46 of whom had new conditions. 133 patients scored over 6 on the 28 item general health questionnaire, 33 of whom were identified as new cases by the general practitioners. 62 patients were seen at follow up, including 23 patients identified by the questionnaire but not by the doctor. The doctors used diagnostic terms to describe the presenting condition in 38 cases. At three month follow up the general health questionnaire scores had fallen by more than 5 points in 22/39 patients identified and managed by doctors and 11/23 identified by the questionnaire. The agreed index of good outcome was almost or completely achieved by 20 of the 39 patients managed by doctors.
Quantifiable methods of evaluating the quality of the structure, process, and outcome of psychological care can be achieved in general practice.
试行一种由全科医生评估心理护理的方法。
通过使用一般健康问卷对全科医疗中提供的心理护理进行前瞻性检查,该问卷在初次会诊时设定了预定的可量化且针对具体病例的结果指标。
北威尔士克莱德郡的农村全科医疗。
447名连续就诊的成年全科医疗患者。
三个月随访会诊率、一年回顾性会诊率、护理连续性、随访时一般健康问卷得分的变化、总体满意度以及结果指标的可接受性。
主任医师和实习医生识别出72例有心理问题的患者,其中46例为新病例。133例患者在28项一般健康问卷上得分超过6分,其中33例被全科医生识别为新病例。62例患者接受了随访,其中包括23例经问卷识别但未被医生识别的患者。医生在38例病例中使用诊断术语描述当前病情。在三个月随访时,在医生识别并处理的39例患者中有22例、经问卷识别的23例患者中有11例,其一般健康问卷得分下降超过5分。在医生处理的39例患者中,有20例几乎或完全达到了商定的良好结果指标。
在全科医疗中可以实现对心理护理的结构、过程和结果质量进行量化评估的方法。