Browne P J, Benchimol A, Desser K B, Sheasby C
Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn. 1978;4(1):15-27. doi: 10.1002/ccd.1810040103.
The electrocardiograms (ECG) of 64 subjects who exhibited an echocardiographically demonstrable increase in thickness of the interventricular septum and left ventricular posterior wall (Group 1, 22 patients), isolated left ventricular internal dimension (Group 2,26 patients), combined wall thickness and chamber diameter (Group 3, 2 patients), and septal thickness, (Group 4, asymmetric septal hypertrophy, 14 patients) were reviewed in order to determine sensitivity of ECG criteria for the diagnosis of left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) proposed in 1949 by Sokolow and Lyon (13), in 1968 by Romhilt and Estes (14), and in 1973 the New York Heart Association (15). Relative sensitivity of the three methods was as follows: Total group, NYHA (77%) greater than Sokolow and Lyon (67%) greater than Romhilt and Estes (58%); Group 1, NYHA (91%) greater than Sokolow and Lyon (73%) greater than Romhilt and Estes (54%); Group 2, NYHA and Sokolow and Lyon (65%) greater than Romhilt and Estes (61%); Group 4, NYHA (79%) greater than Sokolow and Lyon (64%) greater than Romhilt and Estes (57%). We conclude that 1)ECG criteria of the NYHA for the diagnosis of LVH correlate best with an increase of ultrasonically determined septal, left ventricular posterior wall or left ventricular internal dimensions when compared with voltage criteria of Sokolow and Lyon and the point score system of Romhilt and Estes; and 2) isolated increase of left ventricular internal dimension, in the absence of thickened septum or posterior left ventricular wall, frequently results in ECG criteria compatible with the diagnosis of LVH.
对64例受试者的心电图(ECG)进行了回顾,这些受试者表现为超声心动图显示室间隔和左心室后壁厚度增加(第1组,22例患者)、单纯左心室内径增加(第2组,26例患者)、室壁厚度和腔径均增加(第3组,2例患者)以及室间隔厚度增加(第4组,不对称性室间隔肥厚,14例患者),目的是确定1949年由索科洛夫和里昂(13)、1968年由罗姆希尔特和埃斯蒂斯(14)以及1973年纽约心脏协会(15)提出的诊断左心室肥厚(LVH)的心电图标准的敏感性。三种方法的相对敏感性如下:总体组,纽约心脏协会(77%)大于索科洛夫和里昂(67%)大于罗姆希尔特和埃斯蒂斯(58%);第1组,纽约心脏协会(91%)大于索科洛夫和里昂(73%)大于罗姆希尔特和埃斯蒂斯(54%);第2组,纽约心脏协会和索科洛夫和里昂(65%)大于罗姆希尔特和埃斯蒂斯(61%);第4组,纽约心脏协会(79%)大于索科洛夫和里昂(64%)大于罗姆希尔特和埃斯蒂斯(57%)。我们得出结论:1)与索科洛夫和里昂的电压标准以及罗姆希尔特和埃斯蒂斯的积分系统相比,纽约心脏协会诊断LVH的心电图标准与超声测定的室间隔、左心室后壁或左心室内径增加的相关性最佳;2)在没有室间隔或左心室后壁增厚的情况下,单纯左心室内径增加经常导致符合LVH诊断的心电图标准。