Rappaport Z H
Department of Neurosurgery, Beilinson Medical Center, Petah Tikva, Tel Aviv University Medical School, Israel.
Med Law. 1992;11(5-6):449-53.
Brain operations for psychiatric illness were in the past the centre of public controversy. Fear of untoward side-effects and an exaggerated use of the procedure including treatment of societal aspects of the disease process caused a virtual cessation of psychosurgical operations. With the introduction of techniques that could accurately lesion specific areas in the brain, especially in the limbic system, psychosurgical procedures were revived. Psychiatric syndromes, such as obsessive-compulsive affective disorders, were shown to have benefited from such intervention, without giving rise to untoward side-effects. Given societal supervision it is appropriate to reconsider the use of psychosurgery in well-defined clinical entities of mental disease that do not respond to alternative therapy.
过去,针对精神疾病的脑部手术一直是公众争议的焦点。对不良副作用的担忧以及对该手术的过度使用,包括将其用于治疗疾病过程中的社会层面问题,导致精神外科手术几乎停止。随着能够精确损毁大脑特定区域(尤其是边缘系统)技术的引入,精神外科手术得以复兴。事实证明,诸如强迫性情感障碍等精神综合征受益于此类干预,且未产生不良副作用。在社会监督下,重新考虑在明确界定的、对替代疗法无反应的精神疾病临床病例中使用精神外科手术是合适的。