Ginsberg G M, Berger S, Shouval D
Department of Data Analysis, Ministry of Health, Jerusalem, Israel.
Bull World Health Organ. 1992;70(6):757-67.
The large decrease in the cost of vaccines against hepatitis virus B prompts a re-examination of nationwide vaccination campaign strategies. The present study estimates the costs and benefits that would result from a viral hepatitis B prevention programme (with no prior screening) targeted at all under-16-year-olds in Israel in 1990 and only neonates in the period 1991-2034. Israel is situated in an area of intermediate endemicity, where the majority of HBsAg carriers are anti-HBe positive. Such a policy would reduce the number of cases of viral hepatitis B in the vaccinated cohort from 654,000 to 270,000 over the period 1990-2059, yielding a benefit-to-cost ratio of 1.88: 1 for the health services only. Inclusion also of the indirect benefits of reduced work absences and mortality would increase the benefit-to-cost ratio to 2.77:1. Even when the benefits arising from the reduction in hepatocellular carcinoma and liver transplants were excluded, the benefit-to-cost ratio for the health services alone would still be 1.41:1. The adoption of such a nationwide inoculation policy appears therefore to be not only medically but also economically justifiable.
乙型肝炎病毒疫苗成本的大幅下降促使人们重新审视全国性的疫苗接种运动策略。本研究估计了1990年针对以色列所有16岁以下儿童以及1991年至2034年期间仅针对新生儿开展的乙型病毒性肝炎预防计划(无事先筛查)所产生的成本和效益。以色列位于中度流行地区,大多数乙肝表面抗原携带者抗-HBe呈阳性。这样一项政策将使1990年至2059年期间接种疫苗人群中的乙型病毒性肝炎病例数从65.4万减少到27万,仅对卫生服务而言,效益成本比为1.88:1。将减少缺勤和死亡率的间接效益也计算在内,效益成本比将增至2.77:1。即使排除肝细胞癌和肝移植减少所带来的效益,仅卫生服务的效益成本比仍为1.41:1。因此,采用这样一项全国性接种政策似乎不仅在医学上而且在经济上都是合理的。