Wolf G T, Fisher S G
Department of Veterans Affairs Laryngeal Cancer Study Group, Ann Arbor, MI.
Laryngoscope. 1992 Aug;102(8):934-9. doi: 10.1288/00005537-199208000-00015.
The recently completed VA Cooperative Study (CSP #268) of induction chemotherapy (cisplatin/5-FU) and definitive radiation (6600 to 7600 cGy) for organ preservation in advanced (stage III or IV) laryngeal cancer demonstrated that, although larynx preservation could be achieved in 64% of randomized preservation could be achieved in 64% of randomized patients, overall survival rates were not improved over conventional treatment (surgery/postoperative radiation). Of 166 patients randomized to induction chemotherapy, 46 had N2 or N3 disease and were analyzed to determine the effectiveness of the organ preservation treatment strategy on control of neck disease and survival. The clinical response of neck metastases to induction chemotherapy was significantly associated with subsequent salvage neck dissection (P = .008). The overall death rate was increased (P = .014) and survival time decreased in patients with less than a complete response in the neck after chemotherapy (P = .15). This was related primarily to failure to control the disease in the neck. The overall survival of patients achieving a complete response in the neck was improved over the randomized group of N2 or N3 patients treated with primary surgery. The findings suggest that response of neck nodes should be assessed independently of primary tumor response in trials of organ preservation strategies using induction chemotherapy, and that failure to achieve a clinical complete response in the neck warrants planned early salvage neck dissection in order to achieve improved overall survival.
最近完成的退伍军人事务部合作研究(CSP #268),针对晚期(III期或IV期)喉癌进行诱导化疗(顺铂/5-氟尿嘧啶)及根治性放疗(6600至7600厘戈瑞)以保留器官,结果表明,尽管64%的随机分组患者能够实现喉保留,但总体生存率并未优于传统治疗(手术/术后放疗)。在166例随机接受诱导化疗的患者中,46例患有N2或N3期疾病,对其进行分析以确定器官保留治疗策略对颈部疾病控制和生存的有效性。颈部转移灶对诱导化疗的临床反应与后续挽救性颈部清扫显著相关(P = .008)。化疗后颈部反应不完全的患者总体死亡率增加(P = .014),生存时间缩短(P = .15)。这主要与颈部疾病控制失败有关。颈部达到完全缓解的患者的总体生存率高于接受原发手术治疗的随机分组N2或N3期患者。研究结果表明,在使用诱导化疗的器官保留策略试验中,应独立于原发肿瘤反应评估颈部淋巴结的反应,并且颈部未达到临床完全缓解的患者需要计划早期进行挽救性颈部清扫,以提高总体生存率。