Antunes José Leopoldo Ferreira, Narvai Paulo Capel, Nugent Zoann Jane
School of Dentistry, University of São Paulo, Avenue Prof. Lineu Prestes 2227, 05508-900 São Paulo, SP, Brazil.
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2004 Feb;32(1):41-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0528.2004.00125.x.
To evaluate different measurements of prevalence and inequality in the distribution of dental caries as to their partial collinearity, and ability in expressing associations with the supply of fluoridated tap water, indices of socioeconomic status and provision of dental services.
The DMFT, the Significant Caries (SiC) Index, the proportions of children with high- (DMFT > or = 4) and rampant- (DMFT > or = 7) caries experience, caries-free children (DMFT = 0), the Gini coefficient and the Dental Health Inequality Index (DHII) were the dental outcomes appraised in a sample comprising 18 718 oral examination records for 11- and 12-year-old schoolchildren in 131 towns of the state of São Paulo, Brazil. Spatial data analysis assessed the association between aggregate figures of dental indices and several covariates.
The DMFT, the SiC Index and the proportions of children with high- and rampant-caries experience presented strong linear associations (Pearson r near or higher than 0.95), and an analogous profile of correlation with indicators of socioeconomic status, dental services and access to fluoride tap water. The same was observed for the DHII, the Gini coefficient and the proportion of caries-free children. These observations involve the perception of variables in each set as interchangeable tools for ecological studies assessing factors influencing, respectively, prevalence levels and inequality in the distribution of dental disease.
An improved characterization of the skewed distribution of caries experience demands the concurrent estimation of figures of prevalence and inequality in dental outcomes. This strategy may contribute to the design of socially appropriate programmes of oral health promotion.
评估龋齿分布中患病率和不平等程度的不同测量方法,考察它们的部分共线性,以及与含氟自来水供应、社会经济地位指标和牙科服务提供情况之间的关联表达能力。
在巴西圣保罗州131个城镇11岁和12岁学童的18718份口腔检查记录样本中,评估的牙科结果包括恒牙龋失补牙数(DMFT)、显著龋指数(SiC)、高龋(DMFT≥4)和猖獗龋(DMFT≥7)儿童比例、无龋儿童(DMFT = 0)、基尼系数和牙齿健康不平等指数(DHII)。空间数据分析评估了牙科指数汇总数据与几个协变量之间的关联。
DMFT、SiC指数以及高龋和猖獗龋儿童比例呈现出很强的线性关联(Pearson相关系数r接近或高于0.95),并且与社会经济地位、牙科服务和获得含氟自来水指标的相关模式类似。牙齿健康不平等指数、基尼系数和无龋儿童比例也观察到同样情况。这些观察结果表明,每组中的变量可作为生态研究中的可互换工具,分别用于评估影响牙科疾病患病率水平和分布不平等的因素。
要更好地描述龋齿经历的偏态分布,需要同时估计牙科结果的患病率和不平等程度数据。这一策略可能有助于设计适合社会需求的口腔健康促进项目。