Lane Cecilia, Leitch Jaina, Tan Xiaohua, Hadjati Jamishid, Bramson Jonathan L, Wan Yonghong
Department of Pathology and Molecular Medicine, McMaster University, 1200 Main Street West, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada L8N 3Z5.
Cancer Res. 2004 Feb 15;64(4):1509-14. doi: 10.1158/0008-5472.can-03-3227.
A major concern for cancer vaccines targeting self-tumor antigens is the risk of autoimmune sequelae. Although antitumor immunity correlates with autoimmune disease in some preclinical models, the mechanism(s) linking antitumor immunity and subsequent autoimmune pathology remain(s) to be determined. In the current study, we demonstrated that intradermal (i.d.) immunization with a recombinant adenovirus (Ad) expressing the murine melanoma antigen tyrosinase-related protein 2 (AdmTrp-2) results in a moderate level of tumor protection against the B16F10 murine melanoma without any vitiligo. Similar immunization with an Ad encoding human Trp-2 (AdhTrp-2) resulted in 50-fold greater protective immunity and produced vitiligo in all of the mice, suggesting that the development of autoimmunity may reflect the potency of the vaccine. Interestingly, delivery of AdhTrp-2 by i.m. injection generated protective immunity comparable with that seen in mice that received the vaccine by the i.d. route, but none of the recipients in the i.m. group developed vitiligo. The cellular and humoral responses in the i.m. immunized mice were greater than in the i.d. group; therefore, the lack of vitiligo was not caused by reduced efficacy of the vaccine. These results led us to hypothesize that vaccine-induced vitiligo was associated with local inflammatory responses. Mice immunized i.m. with AdhTrp-2 did develop vitiligo when they subsequently were injected i.d. with either a control Ad vector or complete Freund's adjuvant, suggesting that vitiligo is initiated by some form of trauma within the skin. Our data demonstrated that autoimmune pathology is not an unavoidable outcome of effective cancer vaccines directed against self-tumor antigens.
针对自身肿瘤抗原的癌症疫苗的一个主要问题是自身免疫后遗症的风险。尽管在一些临床前模型中抗肿瘤免疫与自身免疫性疾病相关,但连接抗肿瘤免疫和随后自身免疫病理的机制仍有待确定。在当前研究中,我们证明用表达鼠黑色素瘤抗原酪氨酸酶相关蛋白2的重组腺病毒(Ad)进行皮内(i.d.)免疫可产生中等水平的针对B16F10鼠黑色素瘤的肿瘤保护作用,且无任何白癜风发生。用编码人Trp-2的Ad(AdhTrp-2)进行类似免疫可产生强50倍的保护性免疫,并在所有小鼠中引发白癜风,这表明自身免疫的发展可能反映了疫苗的效力。有趣的是,通过肌肉注射(i.m.)递送AdhTrp-2产生的保护性免疫与通过皮内途径接种疫苗的小鼠相当,但肌肉注射组的所有接受者均未发生白癜风。肌肉注射免疫小鼠的细胞和体液反应大于皮内注射组;因此,白癜风的缺乏不是由疫苗效力降低引起的。这些结果使我们推测疫苗诱导的白癜风与局部炎症反应有关。当随后通过皮内注射对照Ad载体或完全弗氏佐剂时,肌肉注射AdhTrp-2免疫的小鼠确实发生了白癜风,这表明白癜风是由皮肤内某种形式的损伤引发的。我们的数据表明,自身免疫病理不是针对自身肿瘤抗原的有效癌症疫苗不可避免的结果。