Weaver Christopher S, Jones James B, Chisholm Carey D, Foley Michael J, Giles Beverly K, Somerville Geoffrey G, Brizendine Edward J, Cordell William H
Department of Emergency Medicine, Indiana University School of Medicine, Indianapolis, Indiana 46202, USA.
J Emerg Med. 2004 Feb;26(2):145-50. doi: 10.1016/j.jemermed.2003.05.005.
To determine if droperidol i.v. is as effective as prochlorperazine i.v. in the emergency department (ED) treatment of uncomplicated headache, a randomized, controlled, blinded study was conducted in the Emergency Departments of two urban teaching hospitals. Patients >or= 18 years old with crescendo-onset headache were eligible for inclusion. Ninety-six patients (48 in each group) were randomized to receive droperidol 2.5 mg i.v. or prochlorperazine 10 mg i.v. Baseline characteristics were similar between the two study groups. For the main study outcome, 83.3% in the droperidol group and 72.3% in the prochlorperazine group reported 50% pain reduction at 30 min (p <.01; one-sided test of equivalence). The mean decrease in headache intensity was 79.1% (SD 28.5%) in the droperidol group and 72.1% (SD 28.0%) in the prochlorperazine group (p =.23). It is concluded that droperidol i.v. provided a similar reduction of headache as achieved with prochlorperazine i.v. with a similar incidence of akathisia.
为确定静脉注射氟哌利多在急诊科治疗单纯性头痛时是否与静脉注射丙氯拉嗪效果相同,在两家城市教学医院的急诊科进行了一项随机、对照、双盲研究。纳入年龄≥18岁且头痛呈渐进性发作的患者。96例患者(每组48例)被随机分为两组,分别接受静脉注射2.5mg氟哌利多或静脉注射10mg丙氯拉嗪。两个研究组的基线特征相似。对于主要研究结果,氟哌利多组83.3%的患者和丙氯拉嗪组72.3%的患者在30分钟时报告疼痛减轻50%(p<0.01;单侧等效性检验)。氟哌利多组头痛强度的平均降低幅度为79.1%(标准差28.5%),丙氯拉嗪组为72.1%(标准差28.0%)(p=0.23)。得出的结论是,静脉注射氟哌利多减轻头痛的效果与静脉注射丙氯拉嗪相似,静坐不能的发生率也相似。