Connors Gerard J, Maisto Stephen A
Research Institute on Addictions, University at Buffalo, Buffalo, NY 14203, USA.
Addiction. 2003 Dec;98 Suppl 2:21-9. doi: 10.1046/j.1359-6357.2003.00585.x.
Subject self-reports are the primary source of research and clinical data on drinking behavior. In this report, we review and summarize the current literature on the reliability and accuracy of alcohol abusers' self-reports of alcohol consumption and related behaviors in relation to similar reports provided by collateral informants.
Recent research supports the assertion that subjects provide accurate reports about their drinking and associated consequences. When discrepancies have been observed between reports provided by subjects and collaterals, the subjects' data in almost all cases have painted a picture of poorer functioning. The greatest degree of agreement between subjects and collaterals is likely when collaterals are in frequent contact with the subject, are spouse/partners and are confident about the reports they are providing.
受试者自我报告是饮酒行为研究和临床数据的主要来源。在本报告中,我们回顾并总结了当前关于酗酒者饮酒量及相关行为自我报告的可靠性和准确性的文献,这些自我报告与旁证提供的类似报告进行了对比。
近期研究支持了这样的观点,即受试者能够准确报告自己的饮酒情况及相关后果。当观察到受试者与旁证提供的报告存在差异时,几乎在所有情况下,受试者的数据所呈现的功能状况都更差。当旁证与受试者频繁接触、是配偶/伴侣且对自己提供的报告有信心时,受试者与旁证之间的一致性程度可能最高。