Puzyński Stanisław
Institute of Psychiatry and Neurology, Warsaw, Poland.
Sci Eng Ethics. 2004 Jan;10(1):135-42. doi: 10.1007/s11948-004-0070-0.
The paper presents major ethical, legal and methodological problems related to the use of placebo in mental disorders, especially in depression. It is pointed out that although authoritative groups of experts and numerous publications in the field of psychopharmacology indicate advisability of the double blind design with placebo in clinical trials of antidepressants, in recent years there have been more and more voices questioning legitimacy of this method. Objections of an ethical nature are raised, and reliability of this approach is put into doubt from the methodological viewpoint. These issues are discussed in more detail in the paper. Available alternative solutions should be implemented in psychotropic drug studies. The author shares these objections and doubts of an ethical nature, and believes that the placebo procedure is not a necessity in clinical trials of antidepressants.
本文阐述了与在精神障碍尤其是抑郁症中使用安慰剂相关的主要伦理、法律和方法学问题。文中指出,尽管权威专家小组以及精神药理学领域的众多出版物都表明在抗抑郁药物临床试验中采用安慰剂双盲设计是可取的,但近年来,质疑这种方法合理性的声音越来越多。有人提出了伦理性质的反对意见,并且从方法学角度对这种方法的可靠性产生了怀疑。本文将更详细地讨论这些问题。在精神药物研究中应采用现有的替代解决方案。作者认同这些伦理性质的反对意见和疑虑,并认为在抗抑郁药物临床试验中安慰剂程序并非必要。