Ysebaert Loïc, Truc Gilles, Dalac Sophie, Lambert Daniel, Petrella Tony, Barillot Isabelle, Naudy Suzanne, Horiot Jean-Claude, Maingon Philippe
Radiotherapy Department, Centre G.-F. Leclerc, Dijon, France.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2004 Mar 15;58(4):1128-34. doi: 10.1016/j.ijrobp.2003.08.007.
We report on our experience in the treatment of T1 and T2 mycosis fungoides (MF) with total skin electron beam therapy (TSEBT), with respect to relapse-free rate, overall survival rate, and management of recurrence.
Between 1975 and 2001, 141 patients with MF were referred to the radiotherapy department for treatment by TSEBT. A total of 57 patients were staged as having T1 or T2 disease (24 T1 and 33 T2 patients). A total of 25 received topical therapy before irradiation. Treatment was delivered through a 6-MeV linear accelerator to a mean total dose of 30 Gy, 2 Gy/day, 4 days/week, for 4 weeks. Close follow-up was initiated without adjuvant therapy. Median age was 61 years (range, 19-84), and median follow-up was 114 months (range, 14-300).
Three months after completion of TSEBT, the overall response rate was 94.7%. A complete response was achieved in 87.5% of T1 and 84.8% of T2 patients. Thirty-one patients (54.4%) experienced a skin failure (8 with T1 and 23 with T2 disease) within 1 year. Eighteen patients of 31 received a reirradiation as salvage therapy (6 localized treatment with segmental fields of electron beam irradiation and 12-second TSEB delivering 24 Gy in 12 fractions). Two were treated by topical steroids, and 11 received combination therapy with PUVA (2/10), topical (10/10) or systemic (4/10) chemotherapy, or interferon (7/10). After a second course of TSEBT (4 T1 and 10 T2 patients), the 5-year freedom from relapse rate was 70% vs. 39% in patients having received other modalities. For the whole group, 5-year DFS was 50%. The 5/10/15-year OS were 90%/65%/42%, respectively. In univariate analysis, T1 (p = 0.03), CR after first TSEBT (p = 0.04), and age younger than 60 (p < 0.001) were significant prognostic factor for OS. In multivariate analysis, age younger than 60 years was statistically associated with improved OS (p = 0.001); T stage and completion of CR remained under threshold of significance (p = 0.059 and p = 0.063, respectively). During the mean 86-month period of follow-up from relapse, a second recurrence was observed in 29% of patients.
TSEBT is highly effective in early-stage MF without adjuvant therapy. Management of relapses with local radiotherapy or second TSEBT is feasible, time-saving, and cost-effective.
我们报告了采用全身皮肤电子束治疗(TSEBT)治疗T1和T2期蕈样肉芽肿(MF)的经验,内容涉及无复发生存率、总生存率及复发的处理。
1975年至2001年间,141例MF患者被转诊至放疗科接受TSEBT治疗。共有57例患者被分期为T1或T2期疾病(24例T1期和33例T2期患者)。共有25例患者在放疗前接受了局部治疗。通过6兆伏直线加速器进行治疗,平均总剂量为30 Gy,每天2 Gy,每周4天,共4周。开始密切随访且不进行辅助治疗。中位年龄为61岁(范围19 - 84岁),中位随访时间为114个月(范围14 - 300个月)。
TSEBT完成3个月后,总缓解率为94.7%。T1期患者的完全缓解率为87.5%,T2期患者为84.8%。31例患者(54.4%)在1年内出现皮肤复发(T1期8例,T2期23例)。31例复发患者中有18例接受了再次放疗作为挽救治疗(6例采用电子束分段野局部照射,12例接受第二次TSEBT,分12次给予24 Gy)。2例采用局部类固醇治疗,11例接受了PUVA联合治疗(2/10)、局部(10/10)或全身(4/10)化疗、或干扰素(7/10)治疗。在接受第二次TSEBT治疗后(4例T1期和10例T2期患者),接受其他治疗方式的患者5年无复发生存率为39%,而接受第二次TSEBT治疗的患者为70%。对于整个组,5年无病生存率为50%。5/10/15年总生存率分别为90%/65%/42%。单因素分析中,T1期(p = 0.03)、首次TSEBT后完全缓解(p = 0.04)以及年龄小于60岁(p < 0.001)是总生存的显著预后因素。多因素分析中,年龄小于60岁与总生存改善具有统计学相关性(p = 0.001);T分期和完全缓解的达成仍低于显著阈值(分别为p = 0.059和p = 0.063)。在复发后的平均86个月随访期内,29%的患者出现了第二次复发。
TSEBT在无辅助治疗的早期MF中疗效显著。采用局部放疗或第二次TSEBT处理复发是可行的,省时且具有成本效益。