Goode Patricia S
University of Alabama at Birmingham and the Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Birmingham, Alabama 35218, USA.
Urology. 2004 Mar;63(3 Suppl 1):58-64. doi: 10.1016/j.urology.2003.10.032.
In a randomized, controlled trial comparing biofeedback-assisted behavioral therapy and drug therapy with oxybutynin, both types of therapy were superior to placebo in older, community-dwelling women with urge or mixed incontinence. Behavioral therapy significantly reduced incontinence compared with oxybutynin therapy (80.7% vs 68.5%, P = 0.04). Patients expressed high levels of satisfaction with behavioral therapy, and 97% were willing to continue this therapy indefinitely, compared with 55% receiving drug therapy. Results of recent studies suggest that behavioral therapy without biofeedback or pelvic floor electrical stimulation also results in significant clinical benefits, which should make behavioral therapy a more practical approach in the general practice setting. Statistical analysis showed no significant relationship between posttreatment urodynamic changes and clinical outcomes, and thus, the mechanisms by which behavioral and drug therapies work remain unidentified. In a small trial of combination therapy, patients who received both drug and behavioral therapy experienced significant clinical improvements compared with the effects of monotherapy with either treatment.
在一项比较生物反馈辅助行为疗法与奥昔布宁药物疗法的随机对照试验中,对于患有急迫性或混合性尿失禁的老年社区居住女性,这两种疗法均优于安慰剂。与奥昔布宁疗法相比,行为疗法显著降低了尿失禁发生率(80.7%对68.5%,P = 0.04)。患者对行为疗法的满意度很高,97%的患者愿意无限期继续这种疗法,而接受药物疗法的患者这一比例为55%。近期研究结果表明,无生物反馈或盆底电刺激的行为疗法也能带来显著的临床益处,这使得行为疗法在全科医疗环境中成为一种更实用的方法。统计分析显示,治疗后尿动力学变化与临床结果之间无显著关系,因此,行为疗法和药物疗法的作用机制仍不明晰。在一项联合疗法的小型试验中,与单一疗法相比,接受药物和行为联合疗法的患者临床改善显著。