Tasker R R, DeCarvalho G T, Dolan E J
Division of Neurosurgery, Toronto Hospital, Ontario, Canada.
J Neurosurg. 1992 Sep;77(3):373-8. doi: 10.3171/jns.1992.77.3.0373.
The clinical features and types of pain affecting 127 patients with central pain caused by lesions in the spinal cord were studied and correlated with the results of surgical procedures performed on 103 of them. The surgical procedures consisted of percutaneous cordotomy in 39 cases, cordectomy in 12, dorsal root entry zone (DREZ) surgery in four, dorsal cord stimulation in 35, and brain stimulation in 13. The three most common types of pain in the 127 patients were characterized as: steady in 95% of cases, intermittent (usually shooting) in 31%, and evoked (allodynia, hyperpathia, or hyperesthesia) in 45%. Steady pain was usually causalgic (74.8%) or dysesthetic (27.6%). The only obvious clinical correlation with pain type was the association of intermittent pain with lesions at the T10-L2 vertebral level. Destructive surgery (cordotomy, DREZ surgery, or cordectomy) affected the three chief types of pain differently from treatment with cord or brain stimulation. Destructive surgery resulted in reduction of steady pain in 26% of affected cases, of intermittent pain in 89%, and of evoked pain in 84%, while stimulation resulted in pain reductions in 36%, 0%, and 16% of cases, respectively. The differential effect of destructive surgery on steady and intermittent pain is consistent with published experience. These observations suggest differing mechanisms for the three types of pain.
对127例因脊髓损伤引起中枢性疼痛的患者的临床特征和疼痛类型进行了研究,并将其与其中103例患者的手术结果进行了关联分析。手术方式包括39例经皮脊髓切断术、12例脊髓切除术、4例背根入区(DREZ)手术、35例脊髓背侧刺激术和13例脑刺激术。127例患者中,三种最常见的疼痛类型特点如下:95%的病例为持续性疼痛,31%为间歇性(通常为刺痛)疼痛,45%为诱发性(感觉异常、痛觉过敏或感觉过敏)疼痛。持续性疼痛通常为灼痛(74.8%)或感觉异常性疼痛(27.6%)。与疼痛类型唯一明显的临床关联是间歇性疼痛与T10-L2椎体水平病变有关。破坏性手术(脊髓切断术、DREZ手术或脊髓切除术)对三种主要疼痛类型的影响与脊髓或脑刺激治疗不同。破坏性手术使26%的受累病例的持续性疼痛减轻,89%的间歇性疼痛减轻,84%的诱发性疼痛减轻,而刺激分别使36%、0%和16%的病例疼痛减轻。破坏性手术对持续性和间歇性疼痛的不同影响与已发表的经验一致。这些观察结果提示三种疼痛类型的机制不同。