Smothers Barbara A, Yahr Harold T, Ruhl Constance E
Division of Epidemiology and Prevention Research, National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD, USA.
Arch Intern Med. 2004 Apr 12;164(7):749-56. doi: 10.1001/archinte.164.7.749.
Previous studies in which research-based assessment for alcohol problems at admission was compared with physician diagnoses indicated that many alcohol diagnoses in hospitalized patients were missed. We estimated the extent to which hospital records documented detection of alcohol abuse or dependence and other alcohol-related problems in a national sample of hospital admissions having a research-based diagnosis of alcohol use disorder ("interview-positive admissions"). We also estimated rates of inpatient alcohol intervention and referral for treatment.
A complex, multistage, probability sample was designed to represent nonmaternity, acute-care admissions to nonfederal, short-stay, general hospitals in the contiguous United States. The study included 2040 admissions, 1613 male and 427 female. Research-based diagnoses of current (ie, past 12 months) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition alcohol use disorder were derived from a structured, computer-assisted, personal interview containing the Alcohol Use Disorders and Associated Disabilities Interview Schedule. Information on detection, inpatient intervention, and treatment referral were obtained via retrospective analysis of closed hospital records covering the index visit.
Record-documented diagnoses of alcohol-related problems were found in 40% to 42% of interview-positive admissions. Inpatient intervention rate was estimated at 21% for interview-positive admissions, and treatment referral rate, 24%. For detected interview-positive admissions, estimated rates of intervention and referral were 50% and 53%, respectively.
Estimated rates of detection, inpatient intervention, and treatment referral of alcohol use disorders in hospital admissions were low. Current-drinking hospital admissions should be screened for alcohol problems as part of the admission routine, with further professional evaluation, intervention, and treatment referral as indicated.
先前的研究将入院时基于研究的酒精问题评估与医生诊断进行了比较,结果表明住院患者中许多酒精相关诊断被漏诊。我们估计了在一个基于研究诊断为酒精使用障碍(“访谈阳性入院病例”)的全国性医院入院样本中,医院记录记录酒精滥用或依赖及其他酒精相关问题的检测情况的程度。我们还估计了住院酒精干预和转介治疗的比率。
设计了一个复杂的多阶段概率样本,以代表美国本土非联邦短期综合医院的非产科急性护理入院病例。该研究纳入了2040例入院病例,其中男性1613例,女性427例。当前(即过去12个月)《精神障碍诊断与统计手册》第四版酒精使用障碍的基于研究的诊断来自包含酒精使用障碍及相关残疾访谈表的结构化、计算机辅助个人访谈。通过对涵盖索引访视的已封存医院记录进行回顾性分析,获取有关检测、住院干预和治疗转介的信息。
在40%至42%的访谈阳性入院病例中发现了记录在案的酒精相关问题诊断。访谈阳性入院病例的住院干预率估计为21%,治疗转介率为24%。对于检测到的访谈阳性入院病例,干预率和转介率估计分别为50%和53%。
医院入院病例中酒精使用障碍的检测率、住院干预率和治疗转介率估计较低。应将当前饮酒的医院入院病例作为入院常规检查的一部分进行酒精问题筛查,并根据需要进行进一步的专业评估、干预和治疗转介。