Kolkebeck Tom, Abbrescia Kelly, Pfaff James, Glynn Theodore, Ward John A
959th Surgical Operations Squadron, Wilford Hall Medical Center, San Antonio, Texas, USA.
J Emerg Med. 2004 May;26(4):395-400. doi: 10.1016/j.jemermed.2003.12.020.
Diltiazem is commonly used to treat atrial fibrillation or flutter (AFF) with rapid ventricular response (RVR). Although it is very effective for rate control, up to an 18% prevalence of reported diltiazem-induced hypotension [defined by systolic blood pressure (SBP) < 90 mm Hg], and a mean of 9.7% hypotension have been reported from several studies totaling over 450 patients. This hypotension may complicate therapy. Our objective was to determine if calcium chloride (CaCl(2)) pre-treatment would blunt a SBP drop after i.v. diltiazem, while allowing diltiazem to maintain its efficacy. A prospective, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study was conducted. Seventy-eight patients with AFF and a ventricular rate of >/= 120 beats per minute were enrolled. Half received i.v. CaCl(2) pre-treatment; the other half received placebo. All patients then received i.v. diltiazem in a standard, weight-based dose. A second dose of CaCl(2) pre-treatment or placebo and diltiazem was given if clinically indicated for additional rate control. Both CaCl(2) and placebo pre-treatment groups had equal lowering of heart rate (p < 0.001). There were no adverse events in the calcium pre-treatment study arm. One patient in the placebo group became paradoxically more tachycardic and apneic after the diltiazem infusion. Although i.v. CaCl(2) seems to be equally safe compared to placebo as a pre-treatment in the management of AFF with RVR, we were unable to find a statistically significant blunting of SBP drop with CaCl(2) i.v. pre-treatment. Until further research determines a benefit exists, we cannot recommend i.v. CaCl(2) pre-treatment before diltiazem in the treatment of AFF with RVR.
地尔硫䓬常用于治疗伴有快速心室反应(RVR)的心房颤动或心房扑动(AFF)。尽管它在控制心率方面非常有效,但多项研究共纳入450多名患者,报告显示地尔硫䓬引起的低血压患病率高达18%(定义为收缩压[SBP]<90 mmHg),平均低血压发生率为9.7%。这种低血压可能会使治疗复杂化。我们的目的是确定氯化钙(CaCl₂)预处理是否会减轻静脉注射地尔硫䓬后的SBP下降,同时使地尔硫䓬保持其疗效。我们进行了一项前瞻性、随机、双盲、安慰剂对照研究。纳入了78例AFF且心室率≥120次/分钟的患者。一半患者接受静脉注射CaCl₂预处理;另一半接受安慰剂。所有患者随后均接受基于体重的标准剂量静脉注射地尔硫䓬。如果临床需要进一步控制心率,则给予第二剂CaCl₂预处理或安慰剂及地尔硫䓬。CaCl₂和安慰剂预处理组的心率下降程度相同(p<0.001)。氯化钙预处理研究组未出现不良事件。安慰剂组有1例患者在静脉注射地尔硫䓬后出现反常性心动过速和呼吸暂停。尽管在治疗伴有RVR的AFF时,静脉注射CaCl₂作为预处理与安慰剂相比似乎同样安全,但我们未能发现静脉注射CaCl₂预处理能使SBP下降得到统计学上的显著减轻。在进一步研究确定其益处之前,我们不建议在治疗伴有RVR的AFF时,在静脉注射地尔硫䓬前进行静脉注射CaCl₂预处理。