Di Paolo Daniele, Tisone Giuseppe, Piccolo Paola, Lenci Ilaria, Zazza Settimio, Angelico Mario
Gastroenterology Unit, Department of Public Health, University of Rome Tor Vergata, Medical School, Rome, Italy.
Transplantation. 2004 Apr 27;77(8):1203-8. doi: 10.1097/01.tp.0000118904.63669.eb.
Cost of long-term prophylaxis with high-dose human hepatitis B immune globulin (HBIg) after liver transplantation is extremely high. The aim of the present study was to assess consumption rates of high (5,000 IU) and low (2,000 IU) doses of HBIg given intravenously "on demand", and determine their cost-effectiveness compared with conventional fixed monthly schedules.
The study included 11 male patients (mean age 53 years) who received transplants for hepatitis B virus (HBV)-related cirrhosis 29 to 96 months earlier, all receiving lamivudine (100 mg/day) prophylaxis. Each patient received three consecutive intravenous infusions of 5,000 IU HBIg, followed by three 2,000 IU infusions. HBIg consumption was assessed by serial measurement of serum hepatitis B surface antibody (HBsAb) titer at 2-week intervals. HBIg was readministered only when HBsAb titers dropped below 70 IU/L (i.e., "on demand").
Mean HBsAb peak titers after high and low HBIg doses were 1,641 +/- 385 and 848 +/- 216 IU/L, respectively (P <0.0001). Mean time to reach an HBsAb titer less than 70 IU/L was 79.5 +/- 38.2 days versus 61.6 +/- 32.1 days, respectively (P =NS). Interindividual variation coefficients were 23 +/- 18% and 32 +/- 26% (5,000 IU and 2,000 IU, respectively). Using the on demand approach, maintenance of a protective anti-HBs titer required an average number of 4.0 (5,000 IU) and 5.6 (2,000 IU) HBIg administrations per year, respectively (P =NS).
Individual HBIg consumption profiles are highly variable. A low-dose (2,000 IU) on demand HBIg administration schedule is highly cost-effective and provides more than 50% savings compared with conventional high-dose monthly schedules.
肝移植后使用高剂量人乙肝免疫球蛋白(HBIg)进行长期预防的成本极高。本研究的目的是评估静脉“按需”给予高剂量(5000IU)和低剂量(2000IU)HBIg的消耗率,并确定与传统固定每月给药方案相比其成本效益。
该研究纳入了11名男性患者(平均年龄53岁),他们在29至96个月前因乙肝病毒(HBV)相关肝硬化接受了肝移植,均接受拉米夫定(100mg/天)预防。每位患者连续接受三次5000IU HBIg静脉输注,随后接受三次2000IU输注。通过每2周间隔连续测量血清乙肝表面抗体(HBsAb)滴度来评估HBIg消耗情况。仅当HBsAb滴度降至70IU/L以下时(即“按需”)才重新给予HBIg。
高剂量和低剂量HBIg后的平均HBsAb峰值滴度分别为1641±385和848±216IU/L(P<0.0001)。达到HBsAb滴度低于70IU/L的平均时间分别为79.5±38.2天和61.6±32.1天(P=无显著差异)。个体变异系数分别为23±18%和32±26%(分别为5000IU和2000IU)。采用按需给药方法,维持保护性抗-HBs滴度每年平均需要给予4.0次(5000IU)和5.6次(2000IU)HBIg(P=无显著差异)。
个体HBIg消耗情况差异很大。与传统高剂量每月给药方案相比,低剂量(2000IU)按需HBIg给药方案具有很高的成本效益,可节省超过50%的费用。