Costanza Christopher D, Longstreth George F, Liu Amy L
Department of Gastroenterology and the Department of Research and Evaluation, Kaiser Permanente Medical Care Program, San Diego, California, USA.
Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2004 May;2(5):395-9. doi: 10.1016/s1542-3565(04)00124-7.
BACKGROUND & AIMS: Chronic abdominal wall pain (CAWP) often is misdiagnosed. We evaluated CAWP patients regarding diagnosis accuracy, clinical features, comorbidity, referral frequency, use of care, and long-term outcome.
We reviewed the records of all outpatients referred to a gastroenterologist in 5 years, recorded referral indications, and identified patients initially diagnosed with CAWP or irritable bowel syndrome (IBS). Charts of all CAWP patients were reviewed, and direct costs were estimated for abdominal pain-related physician visits and imaging studies during the 12 months before and 12 months after consultation. We appraised long-term pain status by telephone.
Of 2709 patients, CAWP was diagnosed by physical examination in 137 patients; the diagnosis remained unchanged after 47.3 +/- 17.7 (mean +/- SD) months in 133 (97.1%) patients. Women predominated over men 4 to 1, pain was usually upper abdominal, had lasted 25.3 +/- 46.3 months, and obesity and painful comorbidities and depression were common. CAWP and IBS comprised 7.8% and 16.3% of symptomatic referrals, respectively. Prereferral, physicians rarely suspected CAWP and often prescribed therapy for acid-peptic disease. Postconsultation, primary care, emergency and specialist visits, and radiologic examinations markedly decreased (P < 0.001), and estimated annual costs decreased from $1133.87 +/- 953.37 to $541.33 +/- 989.04 (P < 0.0001). Therapy varied, and 44 (47.3%) patients had no pain at follow-up evaluation.
CAWP is a common underrecognized disorder. Comorbidities are frequent, and health care use is high. Diagnosis is accurate and reduces health care costs. Over the long term, pain disappearance and persistence occurs in approximately equal proportions of patients.
慢性腹壁疼痛(CAWP)常被误诊。我们对CAWP患者的诊断准确性、临床特征、合并症、转诊频率、医疗使用情况及长期预后进行了评估。
我们回顾了5年间转诊至胃肠病专家处的所有门诊患者的记录,记录转诊指征,并确定最初诊断为CAWP或肠易激综合征(IBS)的患者。对所有CAWP患者的病历进行了回顾,并估算了会诊前12个月和会诊后12个月与腹痛相关的医生诊疗及影像学检查的直接费用。我们通过电话评估长期疼痛状况。
在2709例患者中,137例通过体格检查诊断为CAWP;133例(97.1%)患者在47.3±17.7(均值±标准差)个月后诊断仍未改变。女性与男性的比例为4比1,疼痛通常位于上腹部,持续了25.3±46.3个月,肥胖、疼痛性合并症及抑郁症很常见。CAWP和IBS分别占症状性转诊患者的7.8%和16.3%。转诊前,医生很少怀疑CAWP,常为酸相关性疾病开处方治疗。会诊后,初级保健、急诊和专科就诊以及影像学检查明显减少(P<0.001),估计年度费用从1133.87±953.37美元降至541.33±989.04美元(P<0.0001)。治疗方法各异,44例(47.3%)患者在随访评估时无疼痛。
CAWP是一种常见的未被充分认识的疾病。合并症常见,医疗使用频率高。诊断准确且可降低医疗费用。从长期来看,疼痛消失和持续的患者比例大致相等。