El-Shazly Atef M, Mowafy Nawras, Soliman Mohamed, El-Bendary Mahmoud, Morsy Ayman T A, Ramadan Nashwa I I, Arafa Wafaa A S
Department of Parasitology, Faculties of Medicine, Masoura University, Egypt.
J Egypt Soc Parasitol. 2004 Apr;34(1):265-80.
Out of 105 patients infected with Giardia, 38 patients have Genotype I (36.19%), 13 have Genotype II (12.38%), 10 have Genotype III (9.52%), 16 have mixed Genotype infection (15.24%) and 28 with undetermined Giardia infection by PCR (26.67%). None of the control group gave positive results for Giardia in stool by PCR. So, the sensitivity of the test for detection and identification of Giardia Genotypes from the original stool samples was 73.33% and specificity was 100%. Out of 61 cases in the symptomatic group, the prevalence of Giardia Genotype I was 32.79%, Genotype II was 16.39%, Genotype III was 9.84%, mixed Genotype infection was 16.39% and undetermined Genotype was 24.59% as compared to 40.91%, 6.82%, 9.09%, 13.64% & 29.55% in the asymptomatic group respectively. There is statistically insignificant difference between both groups as regarding the prevalence of the different Giardia Genotypes. (P < or = 0.05). The use of PCR as a routine work for diagnosis of giardiasis is not accepted at least in the developing and under-developing countries due to its high cost, the high quality of technical staff and advanced laboratory equipments required for PCR performance. Its application is usually limited to research activities, the detection of water sources contamination and for the detection of a potential source of Giardia infection in epidemics.
在105例感染贾第虫的患者中,38例为基因型I(36.19%),13例为基因型II(12.38%),10例为基因型III(9.52%),16例为混合基因型感染(15.24%),28例通过聚合酶链反应(PCR)检测贾第虫感染情况未确定(26.67%)。对照组中无一例粪便贾第虫PCR检测呈阳性。因此,从原始粪便样本中检测和鉴定贾第虫基因型的检测灵敏度为73.33%,特异性为100%。有症状组的61例病例中,贾第虫基因型I的患病率为32.79%,基因型II为16.39%,基因型III为9.84%,混合基因型感染为16.39%,未确定基因型为24.59%,而无症状组分别为40.91%、6.82%、9.09%、13.64%和29.55%。两组不同贾第虫基因型的患病率在统计学上无显著差异(P≤0.05)。由于成本高、进行PCR检测需要高素质的技术人员和先进的实验室设备,至少在发展中国家和欠发达国家,PCR作为贾第虫病诊断的常规方法未被接受。其应用通常限于研究活动、水源污染检测以及在流行病中检测贾第虫感染的潜在源头。