Everaert K, Baeyens J
Energy CA n.v., Kunstlaan 1 b3, B-1210 Brussel, Belgium.
J Hazard Mater. 2004 Jun 18;109(1-3):113-39. doi: 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2004.03.019.
Despite the success of adsorption and thermal incineration of (C)VOC emissions, there is still a need for research on techniques which are both economically more favorable and actually destroy the pollutants rather than merely remove them for recycling elsewhere in the biosphere. The catalytic destruction of (C)VOC to CO2, H2O and HCl/Cl2 appears very promising in this context and is the subject of the present paper. The experiments mainly investigate the catalytic combustion of eight target compounds, all of which are commonly encountered in (C)VOC emissions and/or act as precursors for the formation of PCDD/F. Available literature on the different catalysts active in the oxidation of (C)VOC is reviewed and the transition metal oxide complex V2O5-WO3/TiO2 appears most suitable for the current application. Different reactor geometries (e.g. fixed pellet beds, honeycombs, etc.) are also described. In this research a novel catalyst type is introduced, consisting of a V2O5-WO3/TiO2 coated metal fiber fleece. The conversion of (C)VOC by thermo-catalytic reactions is governed by both reaction kinetics and reaction equilibrium. Full conversion of all investigated VOC to CO2, Cl2, HCl and H2O is thermodynamically feasible within the range of experimental conditions used in this work (260-340 degrees C, feed concentrations 30-60 ppm). A first-order rate equation is proposed for the (C)VOC oxidation reactions. The apparent rate constant is a combination of reaction kinetics and mass transfer effects. The oxidation efficiencies were measured with various (C)VOC in the temperature range of 260-340 degrees C. Literature data for oxidation reactions in fixed beds and honeycomb reactors are included in the assessment. Mass transfer resistances are calculated and are generally negligible for fleece reactors and fixed pellet beds, but can be of importance for honeycomb monoliths. The experimental investigations demonstrate: (i) that the conversion of the hydrocarbons is independent of the oxygen concentration, corresponding to a zero-order dependency of the reaction rate; (ii) that the conversion of the hydrocarbons is a first-order reaction in the (C)VOC; (iii) that the oxidation of the (C)VOC proceeds to a higher extent with increasing temperature, with multiple chlorine substitution enhancing the reactivity; (iv) that the reaction rate constant follows an Arrhenius dependency. The reaction rate constant kr (s(-1)) and the activation energy E (kJ/mol) are determined from the experimental results. The activation energy is related to the characteristics of the (C)VOC under scrutiny and correlated in terms of the molecular weight. The kr-values are system-dependent and hence limited in design application to the specific VOC-catalyst combination being studied. To achieve system-independency, kr-values are transformed into an alternative kinetic constant K (m3/(m2u)) expressed per unit of catalyst surface and thus independent of the amount of catalyst present in the reactor. Largely different experimental data can be fitted in terms of this approach. Results are thereafter used to define the Arrhenius pre-exponential factor A*, itself expressed in terms of the activation entropy. Destruction efficiencies for any given reactor set-up can be predicted from E- and A*-correlations. The excellent comparison of predicted and measured destruction efficiencies for a group of chlorinated aromatics stresses the validity of the design approach. Since laboratory-scale experiments using PCDD/F are impossible, pilot and full-scale tests of PCDD/F oxidation undertaken in Flemish MSWIs and obtained from literature are reported. From the data it is clear that: (i) destruction efficiencies are normally excellent; (ii) the efficiencies increase with increasing operating temperature; (iii) the higher degree of chlorination does not markedly affect the destruction efficiency. Finally, all experimental findings are used in design recommendations for the catalytic oxidation of (C)VOC and PCDD/F. Predicted values of the a)VOC and PCDD/F. Predicted values of the acceptable space velocity correspond with the cited industrial values, thus stressing the validity of the design strategy and equations developed in the present paper.
尽管在吸附和热焚烧(C)挥发性有机化合物(VOC)排放方面取得了成功,但仍需要研究在经济上更有利且能实际销毁污染物而非仅仅将其去除以便在生物圈其他地方回收利用的技术。在这种背景下,将(C)VOC催化转化为二氧化碳、水和氯化氢/氯气显得非常有前景,这也是本文的主题。实验主要研究了八种目标化合物的催化燃烧,所有这些化合物在(C)VOC排放中都很常见和/或作为多氯二苯并二恶英/多氯二苯并呋喃(PCDD/F)形成的前体。综述了关于在(C)VOC氧化中具有活性的不同催化剂的现有文献,过渡金属氧化物复合物V2O5-WO3/TiO2似乎最适合当前应用。还描述了不同的反应器几何形状(如固定颗粒床、蜂窝等)。在本研究中引入了一种新型催化剂类型,由涂覆有V2O5-WO3/TiO2的金属纤维毡组成。(C)VOC通过热催化反应的转化受反应动力学和反应平衡的共同控制。在本工作所使用的实验条件范围内(260 - 340摄氏度,进料浓度30 - 60 ppm),将所有研究的VOC完全转化为二氧化碳、氯气、氯化氢和水在热力学上是可行的。提出了一个用于(C)VOC氧化反应的一级速率方程。表观速率常数是反应动力学和传质效应的组合。在260 - 340摄氏度的温度范围内,用各种(C)VOC测量了氧化效率。评估中包括了固定床和蜂窝反应器中氧化反应的文献数据。计算了传质阻力,对于毡式反应器和固定颗粒床,传质阻力通常可忽略不计,但对于蜂窝整料可能很重要。实验研究表明:(i)烃类的转化与氧气浓度无关,这对应于反应速率的零级依赖性;(ii)烃类的转化在(C)VOC中是一级反应;(iii)(C)VOC的氧化随着温度升高进行得更充分,多个氯取代增强了反应活性;(iv)反应速率常数遵循阿累尼乌斯依赖性。根据实验结果确定了反应速率常数kr(s⁻¹)和活化能E(kJ/mol)。活化能与所研究的(C)VOC的特性相关,并根据分子量进行关联。kr值取决于系统,因此在设计应用中仅限于所研究的特定VOC - 催化剂组合。为了实现系统独立性,将kr值转化为以每单位催化剂表面表示的替代动力学常数K(m³/(m²u)),因此与反应器中存在的催化剂量无关。通过这种方法可以拟合很大差异的实验数据。此后,结果用于定义阿累尼乌斯指前因子A本身,它以活化熵表示。对于任何给定的反应器设置,可以根据E和A的相关性预测销毁效率。一组氯代芳烃的预测销毁效率与实测值的出色比较强调了设计方法的有效性。由于使用PCDD/F进行实验室规模的实验是不可能的,因此报告了在佛兰芒城市固体废弃物焚烧炉中进行的PCDD/F氧化的中试和全规模测试以及从文献中获得的数据。从数据中可以清楚地看出:(i)销毁效率通常很高;(ii)效率随着操作温度的升高而增加;(iii)较高的氯化程度不会显著影响销毁效率。最后,所有实验结果都用于(C)VOC和PCDD/F催化氧化的设计建议。(C)VOC和PCDD/F的预测值。可接受空速的预测值与引用的工业值相符,从而强调了本文中开发的设计策略和方程的有效性。