Tafarodi Romin W, Marshall Tara C, Katsura Haruko
Department of Psychology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Pers. 2004 Aug;72(4):785-814. doi: 10.1111/j.0022-3506.2004.00280.x.
The need for separation or individuation is held to be a prime motive in Western psychology. Varied accounts of the meaning of selfhood in Japan indicate that separation may be much less important-or as important-for understanding the construction of self-identity in that culture. We focus here on personal distinctiveness, one vehicle for separation from others. We propose that the desire for distinctiveness is not absent or negligible in Japan, but is subject to more constrained expression than in the West. The results of two studies comparing Japanese and Canadian students suggest that Japanese are less desirous of standing out for their own sake and more likely to experience this form of distinctiveness as aversive. The results also suggest that although Japanese and Canadians derive positive distinctiveness from much the same sources, Japanese are less gratified by this type of experience.
在西方心理学中,分离或个体化的需求被认为是一个主要动机。对日本自我认同意义的各种描述表明,在理解该文化中自我认同的构建时,分离可能没那么重要——或者同样重要。我们在此关注个人独特性,这是与他人分离的一种方式。我们认为,在日本,对独特性的渴望并非不存在或微不足道,只是其表达方式比在西方受到更多限制。两项比较日本和加拿大学生的研究结果表明,日本人不太渴望为了自身而脱颖而出,并且更有可能将这种独特性体验为令人厌恶的。研究结果还表明,尽管日本人和加拿大人从大致相同的来源获得积极的独特性,但日本人对这种体验的满意度较低。