Tremblay Tania, Monetta Laura, Joanette Yves
Institut universitaire de gériatrie de Montréal, Montreal, Canada.
Brain Cogn. 2004 Aug;55(3):427-32. doi: 10.1016/j.bandc.2004.02.068.
It is commonly accepted that phonology is the exclusive domain of the left hemisphere. However, this pattern of lateralization, which posits a right visual field advantage, has been questioned by several studies. In fact, certain factors such as characteristics of the stimuli and subjects' handedness can modulate the right visual field advantage. Thus, the goal of this study was to compare the hemispheric dynamics of right-handers and left-handers during a divided visual field presentation of words that varied in terms of their phonological transparency. For non-transparent words, the left hemisphere seems more competent in both handedness groups. With regard to transparent words, the right hemisphere of both groups also appears competent. Surprisingly, left-handers achieved optimal processing with a functionally isolated left hemisphere, whereas right-handers needed the participation of both hemispheres. The pattern of performance cannot be fully explained by either the callosal or the direct access model.
人们普遍认为语音是左半球的专属领域。然而,这种假定右视野优势的偏侧化模式受到了多项研究的质疑。事实上,诸如刺激特征和受试者的利手等某些因素会调节右视野优势。因此,本研究的目的是比较右利手和左利手在呈现语音透明度不同的单词时的半球动态。对于不透明单词,在两个利手组中左半球似乎更具优势。对于透明单词,两组的右半球也表现出优势。令人惊讶的是,左利手通过功能上孤立的左半球实现了最佳处理,而右利手则需要两个半球的参与。这种表现模式无法用胼胝体或直接通路模型完全解释。