Cooke Cindy M, Shaw George, Lester John N, Collins Chris D
Department of Environmental Science and Technology, Imperial College London, Silwood Park Campus, Ascot, Berkshire SL5 7PY, UK.
Sci Total Environ. 2004 Aug 15;329(1-3):197-213. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2004.02.021.
Two groups of chemicals are currently licensed for use in sheep dip products in the UK. These are organophosphate (OP) insecticides and synthetic pyrethroid (SP) insecticides. SPs are deemed to be less toxic to human health than OPs, although they are approximately 100 times more toxic to some elements of the aquatic environment. Three insecticides were selected for experimental investigation: diazinon, propetamphos (OPs) and cis-permethrin (SP), representative of the active ingredients used in sheep dip formulations, with additional uses in insect control in crops, and for domestic control of flies, mosquitoes, cockroaches, lice, ticks and spiders. The UK Government has recently reviewed agricultural practices relating to the disposal of used sheep dip, because the constituent insecticides are frequently detected in UK watercourses and the presence of these compounds is a severe hazard to the aquatic environment. Standard batch sorption experiments were carried out to investigate insecticide partitioning from water to soil, and the relationship between sorption and soil organic carbon content is discussed. Sorption isotherms and K(d) values showed that cis-permethrin adsorption was fastest on all five soils investigated, exhibiting the greatest total partitioning to the soil phase (83.8-94.8%) and high resistance to desorption. In comparison, the OP insecticides exhibited moderately strong soil adsorption as evidenced by their K(d) coefficients (diazinon K(d) 12-35 and propetamphos K(d) 9-60), with low sorption reversibility (< 15%). Calculation of a hydrological retardation factor in a scenario representative of a typical UK environment suggested that SP insecticides such as cis-permethrin will not migrate in the soil profile due to their virtual immobility and strong soil retention, and thus waste sheep dip disposal to agricultural land should not pose a risk to aquatic life if applied with appropriate controls.
目前在英国,有两类化学品被许可用于羊药浴产品。它们是有机磷(OP)杀虫剂和拟除虫菊酯(SP)杀虫剂。尽管SP对某些水生环境元素的毒性约为OP的100倍,但人们认为SP对人类健康的毒性低于OP。选择了三种杀虫剂进行实验研究:二嗪农、丙溴磷(OP类)和顺式氯菊酯(SP类),它们是羊药浴制剂中使用的活性成分的代表,还可用于作物害虫防治以及家庭中苍蝇、蚊子、蟑螂、虱子、蜱虫和蜘蛛的防治。英国政府最近审查了与废弃羊药浴处理相关的农业做法,因为在英国水道中经常检测到其所含的杀虫剂成分,这些化合物的存在对水生环境构成严重危害。进行了标准批次吸附实验,以研究杀虫剂从水到土壤的分配情况,并讨论了吸附与土壤有机碳含量之间的关系。吸附等温线和K(d)值表明,在所研究的所有五种土壤上,顺式氯菊酯的吸附最快,在土壤相中的总分配率最高(83.8 - 94.8%),且对解吸具有高抗性。相比之下,OP类杀虫剂表现出中等强度的土壤吸附作用,其K(d)系数证明了这一点(二嗪农K(d)为1十二 - 35,丙溴磷K(d)为9 - 60),吸附可逆性较低(< 15%)。在一个代表典型英国环境的情景中计算水文阻滞因子表明,由于顺式氯菊酯等SP类杀虫剂实际上不具有迁移性且在土壤中保留能力强,它们不会在土壤剖面中迁移,因此,如果进行适当控制,将废弃羊药浴施用于农田对水生生物不应构成风险。