Ananth J, Parameswaran S, Gunatilake S
Metropolitan State Hospital, 11401 Bloomfield Avenue, Norwalk, CA 90650, USA.
Curr Pharm Des. 2004;10(18):2231-8. doi: 10.2174/1381612043384033.
The administration of more than one drug for a single medical condition is considered to be polypharmacy. There are many possible reasons for polypharmacy: (1) psychosis is a chronic disease that cannot be cured; (2) expectations to improve patients' quality of life beyond what drugs can actually do is high; (3) the lack of side effects and interactions can cause physicians to be more daring in terms of potential complications; (4) information from the Internet may cause patients and their families to demand medications; (5) the diluted mental health system allows legal guardians and other mental health professionals to force physicians to provide multiple drugs; (6) many new drugs are available; and (7) physicians are forced to shorten hospitalization days. The 1997 American Psychiatric Association Practice Research Network found that 17% of 146 patients with schizophrenia were treated concurrently with more than one antipsychotic medication. Polypharmacy may increase the risk of adverse effects, drug interactions, noncompliance, and medication errors. It is not wise to use polypharmacy only to prevent side effects and drug and interactions. Our attempts to reduce polypharmacy may fail, as academicians also propagate polypharmacy, and all of the algorithms indicate polypharmacy as an option, putting physicians in a legal and ethical bind. Techniques such as experimental ward, peer review, computer information feedback, and comparing different techniques may temporarily reduce polypharmacy but long-term outcome is not affected. Scientific data on the efficacy of polypharmacy is needed in order to sort out good and bad polypharmacy.
针对单一病症使用多种药物被视为联合用药。联合用药存在许多可能的原因:(1)精神病是一种无法治愈的慢性病;(2)改善患者生活质量的期望高于药物实际所能达到的效果;(3)缺乏副作用和相互作用可能会使医生在潜在并发症方面更加大胆;(4)来自互联网的信息可能会导致患者及其家属要求用药;(5)薄弱的心理健康系统使法定监护人及其他心理健康专业人员能够迫使医生提供多种药物;(6)有许多新药可供使用;(7)医生被迫缩短住院天数。1997年美国精神病学协会实践研究网络发现,146名精神分裂症患者中有17%同时接受不止一种抗精神病药物治疗。联合用药可能会增加不良反应、药物相互作用、不依从性和用药错误的风险。仅为预防副作用以及药物和相互作用而使用联合用药并不明智。我们减少联合用药的尝试可能会失败,因为学者们也在宣扬联合用药,而且所有的算法都将联合用药列为一种选择,这使医生陷入法律和伦理困境。诸如试验病房、同行评审、计算机信息反馈以及比较不同技术等方法可能会暂时减少联合用药,但长期效果并无影响。需要关于联合用药疗效的科学数据,以便区分联合用药的优劣。