Denic Srdjan, Khatib Falah, Saadi Hussein
Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, UAE University, PO Box 17666, Al Ain, UAE.
J Public Health (Oxf). 2004 Jun;26(2):168-71. doi: 10.1093/pubmed/fdh131.
Age misreporting is common in demographic studies but the prevalence and magnitude of age misreporting in clinical cohorts is unknown. We analysed single-year age distribution and terminal digit preference in cancer patients from developing countries.
Age distribution was analysed by plotting a single-year age of 3874 cancer patients from 72 different countries, mainly from the Indian subcontinent and the Middle East, who resided in the UAE at the time of cancer diagnosis. Preference for age ending with digits '0' and '5' was evaluated using Whipple's index (WI), which has value 100 in cohorts without preference. Preference for all 10 terminal digits was expressed as the difference between the found and expected frequencies using Myers blended method and was graphed.
Age data quality was low in cancer patients from the Indian subcontinent (WI = 177) and Middle Eastern countries (WI = 113-204). Females of all nationalities supplied better quality of age data (lower WI) than males. Preference for age ending with digits '0' and '5' was found in all populations except the UAE male citizens who did not show preference for terminal digit '0'.
Age data quality in this cohort of patients from developing countries was low. Preference for age ending with numbers '0' and '5' is common. In studies conducted in developing countries, age data quality should be analysed as it may bias results and weaken the power of the study.
年龄误报在人口统计学研究中很常见,但临床队列中年龄误报的患病率和程度尚不清楚。我们分析了来自发展中国家的癌症患者的单岁年龄分布和尾数偏好。
通过绘制来自72个不同国家(主要来自印度次大陆和中东)的3874名癌症患者的单岁年龄分布进行分析,这些患者在癌症诊断时居住在阿联酋。使用惠普尔指数(WI)评估以数字“0”和“5”结尾的年龄偏好,在没有偏好的队列中该指数值为100。使用迈尔斯混合法将所有10个尾数的偏好表示为发现频率与预期频率之间的差异,并绘制图表。
来自印度次大陆(WI = 177)和中东国家(WI = 113 - 204)的癌症患者的年龄数据质量较低。所有国籍的女性提供的年龄数据质量(WI较低)均优于男性。除阿联酋男性公民对尾数“0”没有偏好外,所有人群都存在以数字“0”和“5”结尾的年龄偏好。
该发展中国家患者队列的年龄数据质量较低。以数字“0”和“5”结尾的年龄偏好很常见。在发展中国家进行的研究中,应分析年龄数据质量,因为它可能会使结果产生偏差并削弱研究的效力。