Singer Richard B
American Academy of Insurance Medicine, USA.
J Insur Med. 2002;34(2):89-91.
The objective of this abstract is to demonstrate by life table methodology a significant reduction in the mean annual incidence rate of colorectal cancer in randomized groups with annual or biennial screening for fecal occult blood, as compared with the annual incidence rate in the control group.
Testing for the presence of fecal occult blood has long been used for the early detection of colorectal polyps and potential cancers. The Minnesota Colon Cancer Study, in an earlier report, has shown that colorectal cancer mortality was significantly reduced, but a 12% reduction in incidence of colorectal cancer was not statistically significant. Follow-up in the Minnesota Study has now been extended to 18 years for augmented incidence results, which have now been reported in the source article and in this morbidity abstract.
Subjects in Minnesota were recruited in 1975-1978 and randomized into annual or biennial screening for fecal occult blood, and a control group receiving "usual care." Screening was continued 1976-1982, discontinued, then resumed 1986-1992. During 18 years of follow-up, about 235,000 person-years of exposure were accumulated in each randomized group, with 417 and 435 cases of colorectal cancer in each of the screening groups and 507 cases in the control group.
Aggregate mean annual incidence rates of colorectal cancer were significantly lower in both screening groups than in the control group, as shown in Table 1. In the source article the same was true for the 18-year cumulative incidence rates, which were also significantly reduced (p < 0.001 for the annual screening group and p = 0.002 for the biennial screening group).
本摘要的目的是通过生命表方法证明,与对照组的年发病率相比,接受每年或每两年一次粪便潜血筛查的随机分组人群中,结直肠癌的年均发病率显著降低。
长期以来,粪便潜血检测一直用于结直肠息肉和潜在癌症的早期检测。明尼苏达结肠癌研究在早期报告中表明,结直肠癌死亡率显著降低,但结直肠癌发病率降低12%在统计学上并不显著。明尼苏达研究的随访现已延长至18年,以获取更多的发病率结果,这些结果已在原文及本发病率摘要中报告。
明尼苏达的受试者于1975 - 1978年招募,随机分为每年或每两年进行一次粪便潜血筛查组,以及接受“常规护理”的对照组。筛查在1976 - 1982年持续进行,之后中断,然后在1986 - 1992年恢复。在18年的随访期间,每个随机分组人群累计约23.5万人年的暴露时间,筛查组每组有417例和435例结直肠癌病例,对照组有507例。
如表1所示,两个筛查组的结直肠癌总体年均发病率均显著低于对照组。在原文中,18年累积发病率也是如此,同样显著降低(年度筛查组p < 0.001,两年一次筛查组p = 0.002)。