Prandoni Paolo, Lensing Anthonie W A, Prins Martin H, Frulla Michela, Marchiori Antonio, Bernardi Enrico, Tormene Daniela, Mosena Laura, Pagnan Antonio, Girolami Antonio
Department of Medical and Surgical Sciences, University Hospital of Padua, Padua, Italy.
Ann Intern Med. 2004 Aug 17;141(4):249-56. doi: 10.7326/0003-4819-141-4-200408170-00004.
Because only limited evidence suggests that elastic stockings prevent the post-thrombotic syndrome in patients with symptomatic deep venous thrombosis (DVT), these stockings are not widely used.
To evaluate the efficacy of compression elastic stockings for prevention of the post-thrombotic syndrome in patients with proximal DVT.
Randomized, controlled clinical trial.
University hospital.
180 consecutive patients with a first episode of symptomatic proximal DVT who received conventional anticoagulant treatment.
Before discharge, patients were randomly assigned to wear or not wear below-knee compression elastic stockings (30 to 40 mm Hg at the ankle) for 2 years. Follow-up was performed for up to 5 years.
The presence and severity of the post-thrombotic syndrome were scored by using a standardized scale.
Post-thrombotic sequelae developed in 44 of 90 controls (severe in 10) and in 23 of 90 patients wearing elastic stockings (severe in 3). All but 1 event developed in the first 2 years. The cumulative incidence of the post-thrombotic syndrome in the control group versus the elastic stockings group was 40.0% (95% CI, 29.9% to 50.1%) versus 21.1% (CI, 12.7% to 29.5%) after 6 months, 46.7% (CI, 36.4% to 57.0%) versus 22.2% (CI, 13.8% to 30.7%) after 1 year, and 49.1% (CI, 38.7% to 59.4%) versus 24.5% (CI, 15.6% to 33.4%) after 2 years. After adjustment for baseline characteristics, the hazard ratio for the post-thrombotic syndrome in the elastic stockings group compared with controls was 0.49 (CI, 0.29 to 0.84; P = 0.011).
This study lacked a double-blind design.
Post-thrombotic sequelae develop in almost half of patients with proximal DVT. Below-knee compression elastic stockings reduce this rate by approximately 50%.
仅有有限的证据表明弹力袜可预防有症状的深静脉血栓形成(DVT)患者发生血栓形成后综合征,因此这些弹力袜未得到广泛应用。
评估加压弹力袜预防近端DVT患者发生血栓形成后综合征的疗效。
随机对照临床试验。
大学医院。
180例首次发生有症状近端DVT且接受传统抗凝治疗的连续患者。
出院前,患者被随机分配穿着或不穿着膝下加压弹力袜(踝部压力为30至40 mmHg),为期2年。随访长达5年。
采用标准化量表对血栓形成后综合征的存在情况和严重程度进行评分。
90例对照组中有44例出现血栓形成后后遗症(10例为重度),90例穿着弹力袜的患者中有23例出现(3例为重度)。除1例事件外,所有事件均在头2年内发生。对照组与弹力袜组血栓形成后综合征的累积发生率在6个月时分别为40.0%(95%CI,29.9%至50.1%)和21.1%(CI,12.7%至29.5%),1年后分别为46.7%(CI,36.4%至57.0%)和22.2%(CI,13.8%至30.7%),2年后分别为49.1%(CI,38.7%至59.4%)和24.5%(CI,15.6%至33.4%)。在对基线特征进行调整后,弹力袜组与对照组相比,血栓形成后综合征的风险比为0.49(CI,0.29至0.84;P = 0.011)。
本研究缺乏双盲设计。
近端DVT患者中近一半会出现血栓形成后后遗症。膝下加压弹力袜可使这一发生率降低约50%。