Sligl Wendy, McAlister Finlay A, Ezekowitz Justin, Armstrong Paul W
Division of General Internal Medicine, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Am J Cardiol. 2004 Aug 15;94(4):443-7. doi: 10.1016/j.amjcard.2004.04.059.
Several case series published after the Randomized Aldactone Evaluation Study (RALES) have focused on the adverse effects of spironolactone when prescribed to participants not in a trial and the appropriateness of these prescribing practices; however, there is a paucity of data on potential benefits in patients not in a trial. Therefore, we examined data from a prospective cohort study of 1,037 patients with heart failure seen at the University of Alberta Heart Function Clinic. Median age was 69 years, 66% were men, 75% had systolic dysfunction, and mean ejection fraction was 33%. Only 40% of the 136 patients prescribed spironolactone had New York Heart Association class III or IV symptoms, and <25% fulfilled all of the RALES eligibility criteria. Mean daily dose of spironolactone was 23.9 mg; 25% of patients had spironolactone withdrawn after initiation, mostly due to increases in potassium and/or creatinine (9%), gynecomastia (5%), or dehydration/hyponatremia (6%). Only 1 of our spironolactone-treated patients developed serum potassium >6 mmol/L. Cox's proportional hazards analysis confirmed the association between use of spironolactone and increased survival rate (relative risk 0.09, 95% confidence interval 0.02 to 0.39), even though 78% of our patients did not fulfill the RALES eligibility criteria. Thus, although the complication rate was higher, the benefits of spironolactone seen in RALES extended to participants not in a trial who were treated with similar doses and followed closely in a clinic specializing in heart failure.
随机螺内酯评估研究(RALES)之后发表的几个病例系列研究,聚焦于向未参加试验的受试者开具螺内酯时的不良反应以及这些处方行为的合理性;然而,关于未参加试验患者潜在获益的数据却很匮乏。因此,我们研究了来自阿尔伯塔大学心脏功能诊所的一项前瞻性队列研究中1037例心力衰竭患者的数据。中位年龄为69岁,66%为男性,75%有收缩功能障碍,平均射血分数为33%。在136例开具螺内酯的患者中,只有40%有纽约心脏病协会III级或IV级症状,且<25%符合RALES所有入选标准。螺内酯的平均日剂量为23.9mg;25%的患者在开始用药后停用了螺内酯,主要原因是血钾和/或肌酐升高(9%)、男性乳房发育(5%)或脱水/低钠血症(6%)。我们接受螺内酯治疗的患者中只有1例血清钾>6mmol/L。Cox比例风险分析证实了使用螺内酯与生存率提高之间的关联(相对风险0.09,95%置信区间0.02至0.39),尽管我们78%的患者不符合RALES入选标准。因此,尽管并发症发生率较高,但RALES中所见的螺内酯益处扩展到了未参加试验、接受相似剂量治疗且在心力衰竭专科诊所密切随访的受试者。