Jung M Y, Chan M S, Chow V S F, Chan Y T T, Leung P F, Leung E M F, Lau T Y, Man C W, Lau J T F, Wong E M C
Dietetic Department, United Christian Hospital, Hong Kong SAR.
Asia Pac J Clin Nutr. 2004;13(3):261-4.
The use of the knee height caliper is a convenient way to estimate a patient's body weight. However, the equation devised to estimate an individual's body weight was specifically designed for Caucasians and Blacks. Therefore, this study is to assess the suitability of the knee height caliper among Chinese geriatric patients residing in Hong Kong. Over a six-month period, all geriatric patients from an acute care hospital and private nursing home in the Kwun Tong were recruited into the study. Only patients/residents that were considered unstable with ascites; low blood pressure; on cardiac monitors or had respiratory difficulties were excluded. Measurements from the knee height caliper and mid-arm muscle circumference of the patients were necessary for estimating their body weights. The actual body weights measured with calibrated bed, chair or portable scales was compared with the calculated body weights from the equation. A comparison of the mean and linear regression was performed for analysis of the results. A total of 300 geriatric patients (200 females and 100 males) were recruited. The mean MAC and knee height results were as follows: 25.1 cm (SD 3.9) for females and 26.2 cm (SD 3.2) for males; and 45.75 cm (SD 2.09) for females and 48.98 cm (SD 2.09) for males respectively. The mean difference among the male group was 0.4222 (95% CI: -0.54, 1.39) with a mean estimated body weight of 58.1 kg (SD 10.1) and a mean actual body weight of 57.7 kg (SD 9.9). The mean difference among the female group was 2.9649 (95% CI: 2.30, 3.63) with a mean estimated body weight of 51.6 kg (SD 10.9) and a mean actual body weight of 48.6 kg (SD 10.1). A new equation devised from the data is as follows: Chinese males (over 60 years of age) (R-square -0.81) Weight = [knee height (cm) x 0.928 + mid-arm circumference (cm) x 2.508 - age (years) x 0.144] - 42.543 +/-9.9kg of actual weight for 95% of Chinese males; Chinese females (over 60 years of age) (R-square - 0.82) Weight (kg) = [knee height (cm) x 0.826 + mid-arm circumference (cm) x 2.116 - age (years) x 0.133] - 31.486 +/-10.1kg of actual weight for 95% of Chinese females. The results showed that the mean estimated body weight calculated from the knee height equation (for Caucasians) was significantly larger than the mean actual body weight for the Chinese subjects. This study suggests that the knee height caliper is a useful tool for estimating the body weights. However, a multi-center study is necessary to validate the new equation for the elderly Chinese population.
使用膝高卡尺是估算患者体重的一种便捷方法。然而,设计用于估算个体体重的公式是专门针对白种人和黑人的。因此,本研究旨在评估膝高卡尺在居住于香港的中国老年患者中的适用性。在六个月的时间里,观塘一家急症医院和私人疗养院的所有老年患者被纳入研究。仅排除那些被认为不稳定伴有腹水、低血压、使用心脏监护仪或有呼吸困难的患者/居民。为估算患者体重,需要测量其膝高卡尺数据和上臂中部肌肉周长。将使用校准后的病床、椅子或便携式秤测量的实际体重与根据公式计算出的体重进行比较。对结果进行均值和线性回归比较分析。共招募了300名老年患者(200名女性和100名男性)。平均上臂中部肌肉周长(MAC)和膝高结果如下:女性分别为25.1厘米(标准差3.9)和男性为26.2厘米(标准差3.2);女性分别为45.75厘米(标准差2.09)和男性为48.98厘米(标准差2.09)。男性组的平均差值为0.4222(95%置信区间:-0.54,1.39),平均估计体重为58.1千克(标准差10.1),平均实际体重为57.7千克(标准差9.9)。女性组的平均差值为2.9649(95%置信区间:2.30,3.63),平均估计体重为51.6千克(标准差10.9),平均实际体重为48.6千克(标准差10.1)。根据数据得出的新公式如下:中国男性(60岁以上)(决定系数-0.81)体重 = [膝高(厘米)×0.928 + 上臂中部周长(厘米)×2.508 - 年龄(岁)×0.144] - 42.543,95%的中国男性实际体重±9.9千克;中国女性(60岁以上)(决定系数-0.82)体重(千克) = [膝高(厘米)×0.826 + 上臂中部周长(厘米)×2.116 - 年龄(岁)×0.133] - 31.486,95%的中国女性实际体重±10.1千克。结果表明,根据(针对白种人的)膝高公式计算出的平均估计体重显著高于中国受试者的平均实际体重。本研究表明,膝高卡尺是估算体重的有用工具。然而,需要进行多中心研究以验证针对中国老年人群的新公式。