Subash F, Dunn F, McNicholl B, Marlow J
Emergency Department, Royal Victoria Hospital, Grosvenor Road, Belfast BT12 6AB, UK.
Emerg Med J. 2004 Sep;21(5):542-4. doi: 10.1136/emj.2002.003665.
To see whether three hours of combined doctor and nurse triage would lead to earlier medical assessment and treatment and whether this benefit would carry on for the rest of the day when normal triage had resumed.
Eight days were randomly selected; four for team triage and four for the normal nurse led triage. Team triage was coordinated by a middle grade or consultant from 9 am to 12 noon. Times to triage, to see a doctor, radiology, admission, and discharge were recorded. No additional medical or nursing staff were used and staffing levels were similar each day. All patients including blue light emergencies and minor injuries were included.
Median times were significantly reduced (p<0.05) during the intervention to triage (2 min v 7 min, p = 0. 029), to see a doctor (2 min v 32 min, p = 0.029), and to radiology (11.5 min v 44.5 min, p = 0.029). Waiting times at midday were longer for patients in the non-intervention group. More patients were seen and discharged within 20 minutes in the intervention group (18 of 95 (19%) v 2 of 69 (3%) p = 0.0043). No significant knock on effect was demonstrable for the remaining 21 hours after the intervention ceased.
Three hours of combined doctor and nurse triage significantly reduces the time to medical assessment, radiology, and to discharge during the intervention period. Waiting times at midday were shorter in the triage group. There was no significant knock on effect the rest of the day.
探讨医生和护士联合分诊三小时是否能使患者更早接受医学评估和治疗,以及在恢复常规分诊后,这种益处是否能持续一整天。
随机选取八天;四天采用团队分诊,四天采用常规护士主导的分诊。团队分诊由一名中级医生或顾问医生在上午9点至中午12点进行协调。记录分诊、看医生、进行放射检查、入院和出院的时间。未额外增加医护人员,且每天的人员配备水平相似。纳入所有患者,包括蓝光急救患者和轻伤患者。
在干预期间,分诊时间(2分钟对7分钟,p = 0.029)、看医生时间(2分钟对32分钟,p = 0.029)和放射检查时间(11.5分钟对44.5分钟,p = 0.029)的中位数显著缩短(p<0.05)。非干预组患者中午的等待时间更长。干预组有更多患者在20分钟内就诊并出院(95例中的18例(19%)对69例中的2例(3%),p = 0.0043)。干预停止后的其余21小时内,未发现明显的后续影响。
医生和护士联合分诊三小时可显著缩短干预期间的医学评估、放射检查及出院时间。分诊组中午的等待时间更短。当天其余时间未发现明显的后续影响。