Majewski Wojciech, Maciejewski Boguslaw, Majewski Stanislaw, Suwinski Rafal, Miszczyk Leszek, Tarnawski Rafal
Department of Radiotherapy, Center of Oncology, Maria Sklodowska-Curie Memorial Institute, Gliwice, Poland.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2004 Sep 1;60(1):60-70. doi: 10.1016/j.ijrobp.2004.02.056.
To evaluate the relationship between total radiation dose and overall treatment time (OTT) with the treatment outcome, with adjustment for selected clinical factors, in patients with Stage T2-T3 bladder cancer treated with curative radiotherapy (RT).
The analysis was based on 480 patients with Stage T2-T3 bladder cancer who were treated at the Center of Oncology in Gliwice between 1975 and 1995. The mean total radiation dose was 65.5 Gy, and the mean OTT was 51 days. In 261 patients (54%), planned and unplanned gaps occurred during RT. Four fractionation schedules were used: (1) conventional fractionation (once daily, 1.8-2.5 Gy/fraction); (2) protracted fractionation (pelvic RT, once daily, 1.6-1.7 Gy/fraction, boost RT, once daily, 2.0 Gy/fraction); (3) accelerated hyperfractionated boost (pelvic RT, once daily, 2.0 Gy/fraction; boost RT, twice daily, 1.3-1.4 Gy/fraction); and (4) accelerated hyperfractionation (pelvic and boost RT, twice daily, 1.2-1.5 Gy/fraction). In all fractionation schedules, the total radiation dose was similar (average 65.5 Gy), but the OTT was different (mean 53 days for conventional fractionation, 62 days for protracted fractionation, 45 days for accelerated hyperfractionated boost, and 41 days for accelerated hyperfractionation). A Cox proportional hazard model and maximum likelihood logistic model were used to evaluate the relationship between the treatment-related parameters (total radiation dose, dose per fraction, and OTT) and clinical factors (clinical T stage, hemoglobin level and bladder capacity before RT) and treatment outcome.
With a median follow-up of 76 months, the actuarial 5-year local control rate was 47%, and the overall survival rate was 40%. The logistic analysis, which included the total dose, OTT, and T stage, revealed that all of these factors were significantly related to tumor control probability (p = 0.021 for total radiation dose, p = 0.038 for OTT, and p = 0.00068 for T stage). A multivariate Cox model, which included the treatment-related parameters and other clinical factors, revealed that the hemoglobin level and bladder capacity before RT and T-stage were statistically significant factors determining local control and overall survival. The total radiation dose was of borderline statistical significance for overall survival (p = 0.087), and OTT did not reach statistical significance.
The results of our study showed that the treatment outcome after RT for bladder cancer depends mainly on clinical factors: hemoglobin level and bladder capacity before RT, and clinical T stage. An increase in the total radiation dose seemed to be associated with a better treatment outcome. The effect of the OTT was difficult to define, because it was influenced by other prognostic factors.
在接受根治性放疗(RT)的T2 - T3期膀胱癌患者中,评估总辐射剂量和总治疗时间(OTT)与治疗结果之间的关系,并对选定的临床因素进行校正。
分析基于1975年至1995年在格利维采肿瘤中心接受治疗的480例T2 - T3期膀胱癌患者。平均总辐射剂量为65.5 Gy,平均OTT为51天。261例患者(54%)在放疗期间出现了计划内和计划外的中断。使用了四种分割方案:(1)常规分割(每日一次,1.8 - 2.5 Gy/分次);(2)延长分割(盆腔放疗,每日一次,1.6 - 1.7 Gy/分次,加量放疗,每日一次,2.0 Gy/分次);(3)加速超分割加量(盆腔放疗,每日一次,2.0 Gy/分次;加量放疗,每日两次,1.3 - 1.4 Gy/分次);以及(4)加速超分割(盆腔和加量放疗,每日两次,1.2 - 1.5 Gy/分次)。在所有分割方案中,总辐射剂量相似(平均65.5 Gy),但OTT不同(常规分割平均53天,延长分割62天,加速超分割加量45天,加速超分割41天)。使用Cox比例风险模型和最大似然逻辑模型来评估治疗相关参数(总辐射剂量、每次分次剂量和OTT)与临床因素(临床T分期、放疗前血红蛋白水平和膀胱容量)及治疗结果之间的关系。
中位随访76个月,精算5年局部控制率为47%,总生存率为40%。包括总剂量、OTT和T分期的逻辑分析显示,所有这些因素均与肿瘤控制概率显著相关(总辐射剂量p = 0.021,OTT p = 0.038,T分期p = 0.00068)。一个包括治疗相关参数和其他临床因素的多变量Cox模型显示,放疗前血红蛋白水平、膀胱容量和T分期是决定局部控制和总生存的统计学显著因素。总辐射剂量对总生存具有边缘统计学意义(p = 0.087),OTT未达到统计学意义。
我们的研究结果表明,膀胱癌放疗后的治疗结果主要取决于临床因素:放疗前血红蛋白水平、膀胱容量和临床T分期。总辐射剂量的增加似乎与更好的治疗结果相关。OTT的影响难以确定,因为它受到其他预后因素的影响。