Veal Keith, Perry Michael, Stavisky Judith, Herbert Kim D'Abreu
Columbia University Center for Community Health Partnerships, 630 W. 168th Street, P& S Box 100, New York, NY 10032, USA.
J Dent Educ. 2004 Sep;68(9):938-46.
The small number of minorities in the field of dentistry is a serious concern. While the United States as a whole has become more diverse with minorities making up 25 percent of the total U.S. population, only a handful (14 percent) are currently practicing dentistry, and only 11 percent entering dental schools are underrepresented minorities. Pipeline, Profession, & Practice: Community-Based Dental Education is a national foundation-sponsored program designed to address this issue in dental education. To understand the reasons why dentistry attracts so few underrepresented minority (URM) students, we conducted focus groups and in-depth interviews to determine the challenges facing minority students when they apply to and attend dental school. Ten focus groups were conducted with a total of ninety-two minority students (fourteen undergraduate students and seventy-eight students currently enrolled in dental schools) at six universities in four geographic regions. In addition, four in-depth interviews were held with faculty advisors who teach, mentor, and recruit minority students. The major findings of the study are as follows: 1) early and frequent exposure to dentistry and dentists in practice is essential for minority students to consider this profession; 2) while many dental schools have earnestly tried to recruit minority applicants, most URM students find out about dental programs by a family member or friend and not as a result of an intentional recruiting effort; and 3) hearing directly from minority students could be a solid first step in understanding the dental school experience from a different vantage point. This study has important implications for the methods dental schools use to both recruit minority students and foster a learning environment that is sensitive to students from diverse backgrounds.
牙科领域少数族裔人数较少是一个严重问题。尽管美国整体上变得更加多元化,少数族裔占美国总人口的25%,但目前仅有少数人(14%)从事牙科工作,进入牙科学院的少数族裔学生中,代表性不足的仅占11%。“渠道、职业与实践:基于社区的牙科教育”是一项由国家基金会资助的项目,旨在解决牙科教育中的这一问题。为了解牙科吸引如此少的代表性不足的少数族裔(URM)学生的原因,我们开展了焦点小组讨论和深度访谈,以确定少数族裔学生在申请和就读牙科学院时面临的挑战。在四个地理区域的六所大学,我们与总共92名少数族裔学生(14名本科生和78名目前就读于牙科学院的学生)进行了10次焦点小组讨论。此外,我们还与教授、指导和招募少数族裔学生的教师顾问进行了4次深度访谈。该研究的主要发现如下:1)少数族裔学生要考虑从事这一职业,早期且频繁地接触牙科实践和牙医至关重要;2)虽然许多牙科学院认真努力招募少数族裔申请者,但大多数URM学生是通过家庭成员或朋友了解牙科项目的,而非有意招募努力的结果;3)直接听取少数族裔学生的意见可能是从不同视角理解牙科学院经历的坚实第一步。这项研究对牙科学院用于招募少数族裔学生以及营造对来自不同背景学生敏感的学习环境的方法具有重要意义。