Onur Elif, Alkin Tunç, Monkul E Serap, Fidaner Hüray
Uzm., Araş Gör., Dokuz Eylül U Tip Fak. Psikiyatri AD, Izmir.
Turk Psikiyatri Derg. 2004 Fall;15(3):215-23.
Current diagnostic classification systems have provided reliable, objective and valid diagnoses of mental disorders. They present both categorical and dichotomous approaches to mental disorders. However, rigid usage of diagnostic criteria may cause high comorbidity rates. Moreover, these classification systems fail to identify subthreshold conditions, atypical signs and symptoms, and personality traits associated with the core symptoms of a given mental disorder. These subclinical manifestations are clinically meaningful in terms of disability and effects on quality of life. For these reasons, many researchers have begun to develop dimensional or spectral approaches for a number of mental disorders. Studies on panic disorder with or without agoraphobia have revealed a substantial clinical heterogeneity. The panic-agoraphobic spectrum concept was defined to overcome these difficulties. This concept includes DSM-IV and ICD-10 diagnostic criteria together with atypical and subthreshold symptoms of panic disorder, and constitutes a broader band of panic and agoraphobia symptoms. The panic-agoraphobic spectrum incorporates eight domains of clinical features: 1) separation sensitivity, 2) panic-like symptoms, 3) stress sensitivity, 4) medication and substance sensitivity, 5) anxious expectation, 6) agoraphobia, 7) illness phobia and hypochondriasis, 8) reassurance orientation. In this article, we reviewed the spectrum conceptualization of panic disorder and agoraphobia, particularly focusing on the domains of the panic-agoraphobic spectrum and their assessment.
当前的诊断分类系统已为精神障碍提供了可靠、客观且有效的诊断。它们呈现了针对精神障碍的分类法和二分法。然而,严格使用诊断标准可能导致高共病率。此外,这些分类系统未能识别阈下状况、非典型体征和症状以及与特定精神障碍核心症状相关的人格特质。这些亚临床表现在残疾及对生活质量的影响方面具有临床意义。出于这些原因,许多研究人员已开始为多种精神障碍开发维度或光谱方法。对伴或不伴广场恐怖症的惊恐障碍的研究揭示了显著的临床异质性。惊恐 - 广场恐怖症光谱概念的定义就是为了克服这些困难。这一概念涵盖了《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第四版(DSM-IV)和《国际疾病分类》第十版(ICD-10)的诊断标准以及惊恐障碍的非典型和阈下症状,并构成了更广泛的惊恐和广场恐怖症症状范围。惊恐 - 广场恐怖症光谱包含八个临床特征领域:1)分离敏感性,2)惊恐样症状,3)应激敏感性,4)药物和物质敏感性,5)焦虑预期,6)广场恐怖症,7)疾病恐怖症和疑病症,8)寻求安慰倾向。在本文中,我们回顾了惊恐障碍和广场恐怖症的光谱概念化,尤其关注惊恐 - 广场恐怖症光谱的各个领域及其评估。