Friedman Jennifer F, Lee Grace M, Kleinman Ken P, Finkelstein Jonathan A
Harvard Pediatric Health Services Research Fellowship Program, Children's Hospital Boston, Boston, MA, USA.
Ambul Pediatr. 2004 Sep-Oct;4(5):455-60. doi: 10.1367/A04-005R.1.
The objectives of this study were to 1) describe child care staff knowledge and beliefs regarding upper respiratory tract infections and antibiotic indications and 2) evaluate child care staff reported reasons for a) exclusion from child care, b) referral to a health care provider, and c) recommending antibiotics for an ill child.
A longitudinal study based in randomly selected child care centers in Massachusetts. Staff completed a survey to assess knowledge regarding common infections. For six weeks, staff completed a record of absences each day, describing the reason for an absence, and advice given to the parents regarding exclusion, referral to a health care provider, and obtaining antibiotics. Exclusions for the specific illness/symptom were defined as appropriate or inappropriate based on national guidelines.
A large proportion of child care staff incorrectly believed that antibiotics are indicated for bronchitis (80.5%) and green rhinorrhea (80.5%) in children. For 82.2% of absences, the circumstances or reasons for the absence were discussed with a child care staff member. Of 538 absences due to illness that child care staff discussed with parents, there were 45 inappropriate exclusions (8.4% of illnesses discussed), 91 appropriate exclusions (16.9% of illnesses discussed), and 402 cases (74.7%) in which no recommendation for exclusion was made.
Misconceptions regarding the need for antibiotics for URIs are common among child care staff. However, day care staff do not pressure parents to seek medical attention or antibiotics.
本研究的目的是:1)描述儿童保育工作人员对上呼吸道感染和抗生素适应症的知识及看法;2)评估儿童保育工作人员报告的关于a)被排除在儿童保育之外、b)转诊至医疗服务提供者、c)为患病儿童推荐使用抗生素的原因。
在马萨诸塞州随机选择的儿童保育中心开展一项纵向研究。工作人员完成一项调查以评估对常见感染的知识。在六周时间里,工作人员每天完成一份缺勤记录,描述缺勤原因以及就排除、转诊至医疗服务提供者和获取抗生素向家长提供的建议。根据国家指南将针对特定疾病/症状的排除定义为适当或不适当。
很大一部分儿童保育工作人员错误地认为儿童支气管炎(80.5%)和流绿鼻涕(80.5%)需要使用抗生素。在82.2%的缺勤情况中,与儿童保育工作人员讨论了缺勤的情况或原因。在儿童保育工作人员与家长讨论的538例因病缺勤中,有45例排除不当(占讨论病例的8.4%),91例排除适当(占讨论病例的16.9%),402例(占74.7%)未给出排除建议。
儿童保育工作人员中对治疗上呼吸道感染使用抗生素必要性存在误解很常见。然而,日托工作人员不会向家长施压要求其寻求医疗关注或使用抗生素。