Morgan Maria A, Driscoll Deborah A, Mennuti Michael T, Schulkin Jay
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, Research Department, Washington, DC 20024, USA.
Genet Med. 2004 Sep-Oct;6(5):450-5. doi: 10.1097/01.gim.0000139509.04177.4b.
To assess practices of obstetrician-gynecologists regarding carrier screening for cystic fibrosis (CF).
A questionnaire investigating practice patterns and opinions pertaining to CF screening was mailed to 1165 members of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), of whom 565 participate in the Collaborative Ambulatory Research Network (CARN) and 600 were randomly selected.
Of the questionnaires, 64% were returned. Statistical analyses were limited to the 632 respondents whose primary medical specialty was gynecology (Gyn Only) or obstetrics and gynecology (ObGyn). CARN membership was not a significant factor on any nondemographic measure. Almost one-half of physicians do not ask nonpregnant patients their family history of CF or provide them with information about CF screening. The majority of ObGyns (88.7%) ask obstetric patients their family history of CF, and offer CF carrier screening. Almost two-thirds (65.8%) offer screening to all prenatal patients. Among those ObGyns who selectively offer CF screening to pregnant patients, only 27.4% utilized all of the selection criteria in the guidelines. Liability for not offering screening, familiarity with CF, and the ability to interpret a positive screening test were important physician concerns.
The results indicate a need for minimizing the complexity of clinical guidelines for population-based genetic screening, prospective assessment of implementation and focused continuing education for providers.
评估妇产科医生针对囊性纤维化(CF)携带者筛查的做法。
一份调查CF筛查相关实践模式和观点的问卷被邮寄给1165名美国妇产科医师学会(ACOG)成员,其中565名参与了协作门诊研究网络(CARN),600名是随机选取的。
问卷的回复率为64%。统计分析仅限于632名主要医学专业为妇科(仅妇科)或妇产科(妇产科)的受访者。在任何非人口统计学指标上,CARN成员身份都不是一个显著因素。几乎一半的医生不会询问非孕妇患者的CF家族史,也不会向他们提供CF筛查的信息。大多数妇产科医生(88.7%)会询问产科患者的CF家族史,并提供CF携带者筛查。几乎三分之二(65.8%)的医生会为所有产前患者提供筛查。在那些有选择地为孕妇提供CF筛查的妇产科医生中,只有27.4%的人使用了指南中的所有选择标准。未提供筛查的责任、对CF的熟悉程度以及解读阳性筛查结果的能力是医生们重要的关注点。
结果表明需要简化基于人群的基因筛查临床指南的复杂性,对实施情况进行前瞻性评估,并为医疗服务提供者开展针对性的继续教育。