Miguel-Dasit Alberto, Martí-Bonmatí Luis, Aleixandre Rafael, Sanfeliu Pilar, Valderrama Juan C
Servicio de Radiología, Hospital Universitario Doctor Peset, Valencia, Spain.
Rev Esp Cardiol. 2004 Sep;57(9):806-14.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the production of research papers by Spanish authors on diagnostic imaging published in the official journals of two Spanish scientific societies (Revista Española de Cardiología and Radiología) between 1994 and 1998, and to compare publication rates with those of research papers published in foreign cardiological and radiological journals included in Journal Citation Reports.
Specific search profiles were devised to retrieve items from the Indice Médico Español (IME) and MEDLINE databases. The impact factor for non-Spanish journals devoted to different specialties was normalized for the number of papers published.
967 articles were analyzed (301 on cardiac imaging, 666 on radiology). In the former specialty, 50.5% of the items were published in Revista Española de Cardiología, and in the latter, 55.1% were published in Radiología (no statistically significant difference). Impact factor was 2.46 for cardiology and 0.98 for radiology. The percentage of papers published in journals ranked in the top quartile according to impact factor was 38.6% (cardiology) and 17.2% (radiology); the difference was significant at P< .0001.
Although a tendency for radiologists to publish increasingly in foreign radiological journals has been observed, Spanish cardiologists and radiologists publish more than 50% of their research papers on diagnostic imaging in the official journals of their national societies. The differences in the percentage of articles by Spanish authors published in international specialty journals ranked in the first quartile (twice as great for cardiology as for radiology) suggests that Spanish radiologists are joining the scientific international community at a slower rate than Spanish cardiologists.
本研究旨在评估1994年至1998年间西班牙作者在西班牙两个科学学会的官方期刊(《西班牙心脏病学杂志》和《放射学》)上发表的关于诊断成像的研究论文产出情况,并将其发表率与《期刊引证报告》中收录的国外心脏病学和放射学期刊上发表的研究论文进行比较。
设计了特定的检索策略,从西班牙医学索引(IME)和MEDLINE数据库中检索文献。对不同专业的非西班牙期刊的影响因子按发表论文数量进行了标准化处理。
共分析了967篇文章(301篇关于心脏成像,666篇关于放射学)。在前一个专业领域,50.5%的文章发表在《西班牙心脏病学杂志》上,在后一个专业领域,55.1%的文章发表在《放射学》上(无统计学显著差异)。心脏病学的影响因子为2.46,放射学的影响因子为0.98。在影响因子排名前四分之一的期刊上发表的论文比例,心脏病学为38.6%,放射学为17.2%;差异在P<0.0001时具有统计学显著性。
尽管观察到放射科医生在国外放射学期刊上发表论文的趋势日益增加,但西班牙心脏病学家和放射科医生超过50%的关于诊断成像的研究论文发表在其本国学会的官方期刊上。西班牙作者在国际专业期刊第一四分位数中发表文章的比例差异(心脏病学是放射学的两倍)表明,西班牙放射科医生融入国际科学界的速度比西班牙心脏病学家慢。