Andronikou Savvas, Smith Bruce, Hatherhill Mark, Douis Hassan, Wilmshurst Jo
Department of Pediatric Radiology, Red Cross War Memorial Children's Hospital, School of Child and Adolescent Health, University of Cape Town, Klipfontein Road, Rondebosch, 7700 Cape Town, South Africa.
Pediatr Radiol. 2004 Nov;34(11):876-85. doi: 10.1007/s00247-004-1237-1. Epub 2004 Sep 17.
Although CT scanning is used widely for making the diagnosis and detecting the complications of tuberculous meningitis (TBM) in children, the radiological features are considered non-specific. CT is particularly suggestive of the diagnosis when there is a combination of basal enhancement, hydrocephalus and infarction, and even then the diagnosis may be in doubt. In this paper we introduce a new CT feature for making the diagnosis of TBM, namely, hyperdensity in the basal cisterns on non-contrast scans, and we assess which of the recognized CT features is most sensitive and specific.
To determine the sensitivity and specificity of the presence of high-density exudates in the basal cisterns (on non-contrast CT) and basal enhancement (on contrast-enhanced CT) for the diagnosis of TBM in children, and to correlate these with the complications of infarction and hydrocephalus.
Retrospective review of CT scans with readers blinded to the diagnosis, which was based on a definitive culture of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) for TBM or other bacteria. Computer-aided conversion of hard-copy film density to Hounsfield units was employed as well as a density threshold technique for determining abnormally high densities.
The most specific feature for TBM is hyperdensity in the basal cisterns prior to IV contrast medium administration (100%). The most sensitive feature of TBM is basal enhancement (89%). A combination of features (hydrocephalus, infarction and basal enhancement) is as specific as pre-contrast hyperdensity, but has a lower sensitivity (41%). There were statistically significant differences in the presence of hydrocephalus (p=0.0016), infarcts (P=0.0014), basal enhancement (P<0.0001) and pre-contrast density (P<0.0001) between the negative and positive TBM patient groups. The presence of granulomas was not statistically significant between the two groups (P=0.44).
The presence of high density within the basal cisterns on non-contrast CT scans is a very specific sign for TBM in children. This will enhance diagnostic confidence, allow early institution of therapy and could reduce expenditure on contrast medium, scan time and radiation exposure. With the use of threshold techniques we believe that the pre-contrast hyperdensity may be detectable by a computer program that will facilitate diagnosis, and may also be modified to detect abnormal enhancement. Basal enhancement is a sensitive sign for the diagnosis of TBM and should be sought after contrast medium administration when no hyperdensity is seen in the basal cisterns or when this finding needs to be confirmed. The CT scan feature of hyperdense exudates on pre-contrast scans should be added to the inclusion criteria for the diagnosis of TBM in children.
尽管CT扫描在儿童结核性脑膜炎(TBM)的诊断及并发症检测中应用广泛,但放射学特征被认为是非特异性的。当出现基底节强化、脑积水和梗死同时存在时,CT对诊断具有较强的提示作用,即便如此,诊断仍可能存疑。在本文中,我们介绍一种用于TBM诊断的新CT特征,即平扫时基底池高密度影,并评估已确认的CT特征中哪些最为敏感和特异。
确定基底池高密度渗出物(平扫CT)和基底节强化(增强CT)对儿童TBM诊断的敏感性和特异性,并将其与梗死和脑积水并发症相关联。
对CT扫描进行回顾性分析,阅片者对诊断不知情,诊断基于脑脊液(CSF)针对TBM或其他细菌的明确培养结果。采用计算机辅助将硬拷贝胶片密度转换为亨氏单位,并使用密度阈值技术确定异常高密度。
TBM最具特异性的特征是静脉注射造影剂前基底池高密度影(100%)。TBM最敏感的特征是基底节强化(89%)。多种特征组合(脑积水、梗死和基底节强化)与平扫前高密度影特异性相同,但敏感性较低(41%)。TBM阴性和阳性患者组在脑积水(p=0.0016)、梗死(P=0.0014)、基底节强化(P<0.0001)和平扫密度(P<0.0001)方面存在统计学显著差异。两组间肉芽肿的存在无统计学显著差异(P=0.44)。
平扫CT扫描时基底池内存在高密度影是儿童TBM的一个非常特异的征象。这将增强诊断信心,允许早期开始治疗,并可减少造影剂使用、扫描时间和辐射暴露方面的费用。通过使用阈值技术,我们认为平扫前高密度影可能可由计算机程序检测到,这将有助于诊断,并且还可进行修改以检测异常强化。基底节强化是TBM诊断的一个敏感征象,当基底池未见高密度影或该发现需要确认时,应在注射造影剂后寻找此征象。平扫时高密度渗出物的CT扫描特征应添加到儿童TBM诊断的纳入标准中。