积极的手术治疗是否应成为小细胞肺癌治疗的一部分?
Should aggressive surgery ever be part of the management of small cell lung cancer?
作者信息
Waddell Thomas K, Shepherd Frances A
机构信息
Division of Thoracic Surgery, Department of Surgery, Toronto General Hospital, University of Toronto, 200 Elizabeth Street, EN 10-233, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
出版信息
Thorac Surg Clin. 2004 May;14(2):271-81. doi: 10.1016/S1547-4127(04)00004-0.
CMT with surgery and chemotherapy is feasible, the toxicity is manageable, and postoperative morbidity and mortality rates are acceptable. Patient selection is important, and the results of the LCSG trial indicate that surgical resection will not benefit most patients who have limited SCLC. The chances of long-term survival and cure are strongly correlated with pathologic TNM stage. Consideration of surgery for patients who have SCLC should be limited to those with stage I disease and perhaps some patients with stage II tumors. Therefore, before surgery is undertaken, patients should undergo extensive radiologic staging with CT, MRI, and perhaps even positron emission tomographic scanning and mediastinoscopy, even if the radiologic assessment of the mediastinum is negative. Surgery may be considered for patients with T1-T2 NO SCLC tumors, and whether it is offered as the initial treatment or after induction chemotherapy remains controversial [40,43]. If SCLC is identified unexpectedly at the time of thoracotomy, complete resection and mediastinal lymph node resection should be undertaken, if possible. Chemotherapy is recommended postoperatively for all patients, even those with pathologic stage I tumors. Surgery likely has very little role to play for most patients with stage II disease and virtually no role for patients with stage III tumors. Even though chemotherapy can result in dramatic shrinkage of bulky mediastinal tumors, the addition of surgical resection does not contribute significantly to long-term survival for most patients, as shown conclusively by the LCSG trial. The final group of patients who may benefit from surgical resection are those with combined small cell and non-small cell tumors. If a mixed-histology cancer is identified at diagnosis, the initial treatment should be chemotherapy to control the small cell component of the disease, and surgery should be considered for the non-small cell component. For patients who demonstrate an unexpectedly poor response to chemotherapy, and for patients who experience localized late relapse after treatment for pure small cell tumors, a repeat biopsy should be performed. Surgery may be considered if residual NSCLC is confirmed.
手术联合化疗治疗局限期小细胞肺癌是可行的,毒性反应可控,术后发病率和死亡率也可接受。患者选择很重要,肺癌研究组(LCSG)试验结果表明,手术切除对大多数局限期小细胞肺癌患者并无益处。长期生存和治愈的机会与病理TNM分期密切相关。对于小细胞肺癌患者,手术应仅限于I期患者,可能还包括部分II期肿瘤患者。因此,在进行手术前,患者应接受CT、MRI等广泛的影像学分期检查,甚至可能需要进行正电子发射断层扫描和纵隔镜检查,即使纵隔的影像学评估为阴性。对于T1-T2 NO期小细胞肺癌肿瘤患者可考虑手术,是将其作为初始治疗还是诱导化疗后进行手术仍存在争议[40,43]。如果在开胸手术时意外发现小细胞肺癌,应尽可能进行完整切除和纵隔淋巴结清扫。建议所有患者术后进行化疗,即使是病理I期肿瘤患者。手术对大多数II期患者可能作用甚微,对III期患者几乎没有作用。尽管化疗可使巨大纵隔肿瘤显著缩小,但如LCSG试验确凿表明的那样,手术切除对大多数患者的长期生存并无显著贡献。最后一组可能从手术切除中获益的患者是小细胞和非小细胞混合性肿瘤患者。如果在诊断时发现混合组织学类型的癌症,初始治疗应采用化疗以控制疾病的小细胞成分,对于非小细胞成分可考虑手术。对于化疗反应出乎意料地差的患者,以及纯小细胞肿瘤治疗后出现局部晚期复发的患者,应再次进行活检。如果证实残留非小细胞肺癌,可考虑手术。