Rahman A M, Gedevanishvili A, Bungo M W, Vijayakumar V, Chamoun A, Birnbaum Y, Schlegel T T
University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston, TX, USA.
Physiol Meas. 2004 Aug;25(4):957-65. doi: 10.1088/0967-3334/25/4/014.
Compared to other non-invasive methods, the conventional 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) has low sensitivity and specificity for identifying coronary artery disease (CAD). We compared the newly developed high-frequency QRS electrocardiogram (HFQRS ECG, 150-250 Hz) with adenosine sestamibi myocardial perfusion study (MPI)-the most sensitive non-invasive study in cardiology practice. Using advanced 12-lead computer-based ECG software recently developed at NASA, criteria for a positive 12-lead HFQRS-ECG test for obstructive CAD were developed using 300 signal-averaged beats from patients undergoing elective coronary angiograms for evaluation of chest pain. These criteria, which rely strictly upon the presence or the absence of morphologic 'reduced amplitude zones' (RAZs) and not upon the 'root mean squared' (RMS) voltage amplitudes of the HFQRS complexes, were then applied prospectively to 18 patients undergoing MPI. Active CAD was considered present when reversible ischemic defects were present on MPI. Of the 18 patients, 9 had reversible defects on MPI (positive scan), whereas the other 9 had no reversible perfusion defects (negative scan). Patients with a positive nuclear study went on to coronary angiography confirming CAD, except in one patient who had nonobstructive coronary disease (<50% stenosis). Eight of the 18 subjects therefore had active CAD, whereas 10 were judged not to have active CAD. The 12-lead HFQRS-ECG result was consistent with nuclear scan results in 14 of 18 patients. The HFQRS-ECG and nuclear results differed in: (1) one patient who had a low score positive MPI, negative HFQRS-ECG and normal coronary angiogram; (2) one patient who had a small reversible anterior wall perfusion defect, 60% LAD lesion on angiogram but a negative HF-QRS result; and (3) two individuals who had positive HFQRS-ECG results in the face of negative nuclear scans but who did not undergo angiography. 12-lead HFQRS ECG had excellent sensitivity (87.5% based on 7/8 true positives correctly identified) and specificity (no worse than 80%, >8/10 true negatives correctly identified) for identifying CAD. 12-lead HFQRS ECG is an easily performed, inexpensive and potentially widely available technique that utilizes the same leads and electrodes as the conventional 12-lead ECG. It had accuracy comparable to MPI in this study. Resting 12-lead HFQRS ECG appears to be a very promising non-invasive technique for identifying CAD and may represent a viable alternative to many of the more expensive and time-consuming techniques presently utilized for non-invasively identifying CAD.
与其他非侵入性方法相比,传统的12导联心电图(ECG)在识别冠状动脉疾病(CAD)方面具有较低的敏感性和特异性。我们将新开发的高频QRS心电图(HFQRS ECG,150 - 250 Hz)与腺苷 sestamibi心肌灌注显像(MPI)进行了比较,后者是心脏病学实践中最敏感的非侵入性检查。使用美国国家航空航天局(NASA)最近开发的基于计算机的先进12导联心电图软件,从因胸痛接受选择性冠状动脉造影的患者中选取300个信号平均搏动,制定了用于诊断阻塞性CAD的12导联HFQRS - ECG阳性检测标准。这些标准严格依赖于形态学上“振幅降低区”(RAZs)的存在与否,而不是HFQRS复合波的“均方根”(RMS)电压振幅,然后将其前瞻性地应用于18例接受MPI检查的患者。当MPI出现可逆性缺血缺损时,认为存在活动性CAD。在这18例患者中,9例在MPI上有可逆性缺损(扫描阳性),而另外9例没有可逆性灌注缺损(扫描阴性)。核素检查阳性的患者除1例患有非阻塞性冠状动脉疾病(狭窄<50%)外,均接受了冠状动脉造影以确诊CAD。因此,18例受试者中有8例患有活动性CAD,而10例被判定没有活动性CAD。12导联HFQRS - ECG结果与18例患者中的14例核素扫描结果一致。HFQRS - ECG和核素检查结果不同的情况有:(1)1例患者MPI低评分阳性、HFQRS - ECG阴性且冠状动脉造影正常;(2)1例患者前壁有小的可逆性灌注缺损,血管造影显示左前降支(LAD)病变60%,但HF - QRS结果为阴性;(3)2例患者HFQRS - ECG结果阳性而核素扫描阴性,但未接受血管造影。12导联HFQRS ECG在识别CAD方面具有出色的敏感性(基于正确识别的7/8真阳性,敏感性为87.5%)和特异性(不低于80%,>8/10真阴性正确识别)。12导联HFQRS ECG是一种易于操作、成本低廉且可能广泛应用的技术,它使用与传统12导联ECG相同的导联和电极。在本研究中,其准确性与MPI相当。静息12导联HFQRS ECG似乎是一种非常有前景的用于识别CAD的非侵入性技术,可能是目前用于非侵入性识别CAD的许多更昂贵且耗时的技术的可行替代方法。