Grube Eberhard, Bootsveld Andreas, Buellesfeld Lutz, Yuecel Seyrani, Shen Joseph T, Imhoff Michael
Department of Cardiology, Angiology, HELIOS Heart Center Siegburg, Siegburg, Germany.
Int J Med Sci. 2008 Mar 2;5(2):50-61. doi: 10.7150/ijms.5.50.
Resting electrocardiogram (ECG) shows limited sensitivity and specificity for the detection of coronary artery disease (CAD), where patients with a history of coronary revascularization may pose special challenges. Several methods exist to enhance sensitivity and specificity of resting ECG for diagnosis of CAD, but such methods are not better than a specialist's judgement. We compared a new computer-enhanced, resting ECG analysis device, 3DMP, to coronary angiography to evaluate the device's accuracy in detecting hemodynamically relevant CAD.
A convenience sample of 172 patients with a history of coronary revascularization scheduled for coronary angiography was evaluated with 3DMP before coronary angiography. 3DMP's sensitivity and specificity in detecting hemodynamically relevant coronary stenosis as diagnosed with coronary angiography were calculated as well as odds ratios for the 3DMP severity score and coronary artery disease risk factors.
The 3DMP system accurately identified 50 of 55 patients as having hemodynamically relevant stenosis (sensitivity 90.9%, specificity 88.0%). Positive and negative predictive values for the identification of coronary stenosis as diagnosed in coronary angiograms were 62.7% and 97.8% respectively. Risk and demographic factors in a logistic regression model had a markedly lower predictive power for the presence of coronary stenosis in these patients than did 3DMP severity score (odds ratio 2.04 [0.74-5.62] vs. 73.57 [25.10-215.68]). A logistic regression combining severity score with risk and demographic factors did not add significantly to the prediction quality (odds ratio 80.00 [27.03-236.79]).
3DMP's computer-based, mathematically derived analysis of resting two-lead ECG data provides detection of hemodynamically relevant CAD in patients with a history of coronary revascularization with high sensitivity and specificity that appears to be at least as good as those reported for other resting and/or stress ECG methods currently used in clinical practice.
静息心电图(ECG)对冠状动脉疾病(CAD)检测的敏感性和特异性有限,有冠状动脉血运重建史的患者可能带来特殊挑战。存在多种方法可提高静息ECG诊断CAD的敏感性和特异性,但这些方法并不优于专家判断。我们将一种新型计算机增强静息ECG分析设备3DMP与冠状动脉造影进行比较,以评估该设备检测血流动力学相关CAD的准确性。
对172例计划进行冠状动脉造影且有冠状动脉血运重建史的患者进行便利抽样,在冠状动脉造影前用3DMP进行评估。计算3DMP检测冠状动脉造影诊断的血流动力学相关冠状动脉狭窄的敏感性和特异性,以及3DMP严重程度评分和冠状动脉疾病危险因素的比值比。
3DMP系统准确识别出55例患者中的50例存在血流动力学相关狭窄(敏感性90.9%,特异性88.0%)。冠状动脉造影诊断的冠状动脉狭窄的阳性和阴性预测值分别为62.7%和97.8%。在这些患者中,逻辑回归模型中的风险和人口统计学因素对冠状动脉狭窄存在的预测能力明显低于3DMP严重程度评分(比值比2.04[0.74 - 5.62] vs. 73.57[25.10 - 215.68])。将严重程度评分与风险和人口统计学因素相结合的逻辑回归并未显著提高预测质量(比值比80.00[27.03 - 236.79])。
3DMP基于计算机对静息双导联ECG数据进行数学推导分析,能以高敏感性和特异性检测有冠状动脉血运重建史患者的血流动力学相关CAD,其表现似乎至少与目前临床实践中使用的其他静息和/或负荷ECG方法相当。