Boulet Marie-Claude, Ethier Louise S, Couture Germain
Département de psychologie, Université du Québec à Trois-Rivières.
Sante Ment Que. 2004 Spring;29(1):221-42. doi: 10.7202/008832ar.
The present study examines more closely the chronic behaviors of maltreating mothers. Events that these mothers have experienced during childhood are examined, experiences including abuse, placement, separation, bereavement, rejection, neglect, lack of love and role reversal. Signs of unresolved trauma found in the discourse of mothers, such as dissociation, are also studied. It is proposed that negligent mothers from the chronic group will evoke more negative experiences and/or more intense negative experiences which occurred during childhood than the mothers from the transitory group. The chronic group will also show more signs of dissociation. From a six years follow-up study, a sample of 20 mothers was recruited from the Child Protection Services, including the cases of 10 chronic maltreating mothers and 10 transitory maltreating mothers. Two main measures were used: the Child Abuse Potential Inventory (CAPI) and the Adult Attachment Interview (AAI) (Main et Goldwyn, 1998). The experiences from childhood and complete discourse in AAI were analysed with the method used by Main et Goldwyn (1998). Non parametric analysis indicate that mothers from the chronic group evoke more negative and very negative childhood experiences than the mothers from the transitory group. Content analysis show that chronic maltreating mothers relate having gone through more potentially traumatic events such as foster care placements, separations and abuse. The analysis of the Adult Attachment Interview according to Main and Goldwyn's system demonstrate that the majority of the chronic maltreating mothers have two times more unresolved traumas.
本研究更深入地考察了虐待型母亲的长期行为。研究了这些母亲在童年时期所经历的事件,包括虐待、安置、分离、丧亲之痛、被拒、忽视、缺乏关爱以及角色颠倒等经历。还研究了在母亲的话语中发现的未解决创伤的迹象,比如解离。研究提出,与短暂虐待组的母亲相比,长期虐待组的疏忽型母亲会唤起更多童年时期发生的负面经历和/或更强烈的负面经历。长期虐待组还会表现出更多的解离迹象。在一项为期六年的跟踪研究中,从儿童保护服务机构招募了20位母亲作为样本,其中包括10位长期虐待型母亲和10位短暂虐待型母亲的案例。采用了两项主要测量方法:儿童虐待潜在性量表(CAPI)和成人依恋访谈(AAI)(梅因和戈德温,1998年)。运用梅因和戈德温(1998年)所使用的方法,对童年经历和AAI中的完整话语进行了分析。非参数分析表明,长期虐待组的母亲比短暂虐待组的母亲唤起了更多负面和非常负面的童年经历。内容分析显示,长期虐待型母亲讲述自己经历了更多潜在创伤性事件,如寄养安置、分离和虐待。根据梅因和戈德温的系统对成人依恋访谈进行的分析表明,大多数长期虐待型母亲有未解决创伤的情况是其他母亲的两倍。