Haller Reinhard, Dittrich Isabel, Kocsis Esther
Krankenhaus Stiftung Maria Ebene und Universitätsinstitut für Suchtforschung, Feldkirch, Osterreich.
Wien Med Wochenschr. 2004 Aug;154(15-16):356-65. doi: 10.1007/s10354-004-0087-7.
The question of potential violence on the part of people with a mental disease has caused considerable controversy in recent decades. While in the eighties the prevailing opinion was that they have no increased risk of aggression, recent studies, especially from Scandinavia and Canada, show a moderate but reliable coherence between violent crime and paranoid and schizophrenic diseases. The danger of people with a mental disease is assessed essentially through the following five study-approaches: Studies to assess the criminal rate of hospitalised patients, the prevalence of mental disorder, studies on prisoners who are committed to a psychiatric facility, and long-term analyses of cohorts. Special emphasis is attached to investigations on homicides. Other investigative questions are concerned with the influence of psychopathological symptoms, the importance of comorbid disturbances and sociological aspects. The studies agree that the risk of violence is decisively increased in people who suffer from schizophrenia, through additional substance abuse, comorbidity with personality disorders, absence of treatment and social desintegration. An unprejudiced approach to this sensitive theme of aggression in people with schizophrenia with regard to further effective prevention and therapy is required.
近几十年来,患有精神疾病的人是否存在潜在暴力问题引发了相当大的争议。在八十年代,普遍观点认为他们的攻击风险并未增加,但近期研究,尤其是来自斯堪的纳维亚和加拿大的研究表明,暴力犯罪与偏执型和精神分裂症之间存在适度但可靠的关联。评估患有精神疾病的人的危险性主要通过以下五种研究方法:评估住院患者犯罪率的研究、精神障碍患病率的研究、对被送往精神病院的囚犯的研究以及对队列的长期分析。特别强调对凶杀案的调查。其他调查问题涉及心理病理症状的影响、共病障碍的重要性以及社会学方面。这些研究一致认为,患有精神分裂症的人若同时存在药物滥用、人格障碍共病、未接受治疗和社会解体等情况,其暴力风险会显著增加。对于精神分裂症患者攻击这一敏感主题,需要采取无偏见的方法以进行进一步有效的预防和治疗。