Palijan Tija Zarković, Muzinić Lana, Radeljak Sanja
Department of Forensic Psychiatry, Neuropsychiatric hospital Dr Ivan Barbot, 44 317 Popovaca, Croatia.
Psychiatr Danub. 2009 Sep;21(3):429-36.
For the past several years a numerous studies in the field of forensic psychiatry confirmed a close relationship between violent offenders and comorbid substance abuse. The comorbid substance abuse in violent offenders was usually unrecognized and misdiagnosed. Furthermore, comorbidity in forensic psychiatry describes the co-occurrence of two or more conditions or psychiatric disorder known in the literature as dual diagnosis and defined by World Health Organization (WHO). In fact, many violent offenders have multiple psychiatric diagnoses. Recent studies have confirmed causal relationship between major psychiatric disorders and concomitant substance abuse (comorbidity) in 50-80% of forensic cases. In general, there is a high level of psychiatric comorbidity in forensic patients with prevalence of personality disorders (50-90%), mood disorders (20-60%) and psychotic disorders (15-20%) coupled with substance abuse disorders. Moreover, the high prevalence of psychiatric comorbidities could be found in mentally retarded individuals, as well as, in epileptic patients. Drugs and alcohol abuse can produce serious psychotoxic effects that may lead to extreme violent behavior and consequently to serious criminal offence such as physical assault, rape, armed robbery, attempted murder and homicide, all due to an altered brain function and generating psychotic-like symptoms. Studies have confirmed a significant statistical relevance in causal relationship between substance abuse and violent offences. In terms of forensic psychiatry, the comorbidity strongly contributes in the process of establishing psychiatric diagnosis of diminished mental capacity or insanity at the time of the offence in the course of clinical assessment and evaluation of violent offenders. Today, the primary focus of forensic psychiatry treatment services (in-patient or community) is management of the violent offenders with psychiatric comorbidity which requires a multilevel, evidence based approach to the patient. Forensic treatment service effectiveness appears to be associated with individual case management and approach including psychotherapy, pharmacotherapy and occupational therapy in order to achieve optimal rehabilitation, prevention of recidivism and stability in social functioning of the patient in the community.
在过去几年里,法医精神病学领域的大量研究证实了暴力罪犯与共病物质滥用之间存在密切关系。暴力罪犯中的共病物质滥用情况通常未被识别和误诊。此外,法医精神病学中的共病描述了两种或更多种病症或精神障碍的同时出现,在文献中被称为双重诊断,由世界卫生组织(WHO)定义。事实上,许多暴力罪犯有多种精神疾病诊断。最近的研究证实,在50%-80%的法医案件中,主要精神疾病与伴随的物质滥用(共病)之间存在因果关系。一般来说,法医患者中精神共病的发生率很高,人格障碍(50%-90%)、情绪障碍(20%-60%)和精神障碍(15%-20%)与物质滥用障碍并存。此外,在智力迟钝者以及癫痫患者中也能发现精神共病的高发生率。药物和酒精滥用会产生严重的精神毒性作用,可能导致极端暴力行为,进而导致严重刑事犯罪,如人身攻击、强奸、武装抢劫、谋杀未遂和杀人,所有这些都是由于大脑功能改变并产生类似精神病的症状。研究证实,物质滥用与暴力犯罪之间的因果关系具有显著的统计学相关性。就法医精神病学而言,共病在对暴力罪犯进行临床评估和评价时,对确定犯罪时精神能力减退或精神错乱的精神病诊断过程有很大帮助。如今,法医精神病学治疗服务(住院或社区)的主要重点是对患有精神共病的暴力罪犯进行管理,这需要对患者采取多层次、基于证据的方法。法医治疗服务的有效性似乎与个案管理和方法有关,包括心理治疗、药物治疗和职业治疗,以便实现最佳康复、预防累犯以及患者在社区中的社会功能稳定。