Sandson T A, Bachna K J, Morin M D
Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
J Learn Disabil. 2000 Jan-Feb;33(1):83-90. doi: 10.1177/002221940003300111.
The relationship between right hemisphere dysfunction and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) remains controversial. We administered a random letter cancellation test to 58 carefully selected adult patients meeting DSM-IV criteria for ADHD and 29 age- and education-matched controls. Patients with ADHD had a higher mean omission rate on the left side than the controls, and a greater percentage of ADHD patients than controls made more omissions on the left than on the right (L > R errors). ADHD patients who made L > R errors had lower performance IQ scores than ADHD patients who did not make L > R errors. However, ADHD patients who made L > R errors did not differ from ADHD patients who did not make L > R errors in ADHD subtype, medication response, or neuropsychological measures of attention, executive function, verbal memory, nonverbal memory, or academic achievement. Patients without a family history of ADHD were more likely to make L > R errors than patients with a family history of ADHD. This study provides support for the concept of right hemisphere dysfunction in a subset of patients with ADHD. However, ADHD patients who make L > R errors do not appear to represent a distinct clinical subgroup in terms of medication response, ADHD subtype, or neuropsychological test performance.
右半球功能障碍与注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)之间的关系仍存在争议。我们对58名精心挑选的符合DSM-IV标准的成年ADHD患者和29名年龄及教育程度匹配的对照组进行了随机字母划消测试。ADHD患者左侧的平均遗漏率高于对照组,且与对照组相比,有更高比例的ADHD患者左侧遗漏多于右侧(左>右错误)。出现左>右错误的ADHD患者的操作智商得分低于未出现左>右错误的ADHD患者。然而,在ADHD亚型、药物反应或注意力、执行功能、言语记忆、非言语记忆或学业成绩的神经心理学测量方面,出现左>右错误的ADHD患者与未出现左>右错误的ADHD患者并无差异。无ADHD家族史的患者比有ADHD家族史的患者更易出现左>右错误。本研究为部分ADHD患者存在右半球功能障碍的概念提供了支持。然而,就药物反应、ADHD亚型或神经心理学测试表现而言,出现左>右错误的ADHD患者似乎并不代表一个独特的临床亚组。