Williams Nigel, Ogden Jane
Department of General Practice, Guys Kings and St Thomas' School of Medicine, London University, London, UK.
Fam Pract. 2004 Dec;21(6):630-5. doi: 10.1093/fampra/cmh610. Epub 2004 Nov 1.
Research in general practice emphasizes the importance of matched models, beliefs and vocabulary in the consultation.
The present study aimed to explore the impact of matched and unmatched vocabulary on patient satisfaction with consultations.
The study took place in one inner city general practice. Patients (n=62) were randomized to either matched or unmatched vocabulary consultations when consulting for problems relating to sexual or bodily function or anatomy. Matched consultations required the doctor to use the same vocabulary as the patient. Unmatched consultations required the doctor to use medical vocabulary. Completed questionnaires were received from 60 patients. The main outcome measure was patient satisfaction (using the Medical Interview Satisfaction Scale). This assesses total satisfaction and has four subscales: distress relief; communication comfort; rapport; and compliance intent. Doctor satisfaction with the consultation was also assessed.
The results showed that the two groups were comparable for demographic variables and doctor satisfaction. However, patients in the matched consultation group had significantly higher total satisfaction scores and higher ratings of rapport, communication comfort, distress relief and compliance intent than those in the unmatched group.
The results indicate that a doctor's choice of vocabulary affects patient satisfaction immediately after a general practice consultation and that using the same vocabulary as the patient can improve patient outcomes.
全科医疗研究强调在诊疗过程中匹配的模式、观念和词汇的重要性。
本研究旨在探讨匹配和不匹配的词汇对患者诊疗满意度的影响。
研究在一个市中心的全科医疗机构进行。当患者咨询与性功能、身体功能或解剖结构相关的问题时,62名患者被随机分配到词汇匹配或不匹配的诊疗组。匹配的诊疗要求医生使用与患者相同的词汇。不匹配的诊疗要求医生使用医学词汇。共收到60名患者填写的问卷。主要结局指标是患者满意度(使用医疗访谈满意度量表)。该量表评估总体满意度,有四个子量表:痛苦缓解;沟通舒适度;融洽度;以及依从意愿。同时也评估了医生对诊疗的满意度。
结果显示,两组在人口统计学变量和医生满意度方面具有可比性。然而,匹配诊疗组的患者在总体满意度得分以及融洽度、沟通舒适度、痛苦缓解和依从意愿方面的评分显著高于不匹配组的患者。
结果表明,在全科医疗诊疗后,医生的词汇选择会立即影响患者满意度,并且使用与患者相同的词汇可以改善患者的诊疗效果。